Podcast Summary
Exploring Hemingway's Exploration of Manliness: Minneter's book offers a fresh perspective on Hemingway's novel 'The Sun Also Rises', focusing on Hemingway's depiction of manliness and the creation of a new myth of masculinity in modern times.
Frank Minneter's book, "This Will Make a Man Out of You," offers a unique perspective on Ernest Hemingway's novel "The Sun Also Rises" by focusing on Hemingway's exploration of manliness and the creation of a new myth of masculinity in the context of modern sensibilities. Minneter, a journalist and author, was inspired by the question of what makes men and the enduring legacy of Hemingway as an icon of manliness. He delved into Hemingway's writing and experiences, visiting Paris and Spain to participate in the running of the bulls and observing bullfights. Minneter's insights provide a fresh perspective on Hemingway's work, shedding light on the complexities of manhood and the evolution of masculine ideals. The book challenges the simplistic views of Hemingway as a chauvinist and invites readers to reconsider his impact on modern conceptions of manliness.
The Hemingway Man: Authentic Masculinity Rooted in Reality: Ernest Hemingway's depiction of the ideal man emphasizes authenticity, ruggedness, and real experiences, shaping a masculinity that resonates today despite a world filled with virtual experiences and alternate realities.
The Hemingway man, as depicted in the life and works of Ernest Hemingway, embodies a well-rounded, authentic, and grounded masculinity. This ideal man is both sophisticated and rugged, and he seeks out real experiences and adventures to shape his character. Hemingway's exploration of manliness led him to follow in the footsteps of expats in Paris and participate in rituals like running with the bulls in Pamplona. These experiences, rooted in reality, allowed Hemingway to find depth and meaning, and he valued authenticity above all else. He was not impressed by posers and fakes, but rather sought out genuine connections and experiences. Hemingway's commitment to reality and authenticity continues to resonate today, as we navigate a world increasingly filled with virtual experiences and alternate realities.
The cultural shift towards 'cool' overshadowed traditional manly ideals: The loss of clear-cut good and evil in society calls for a return to foundational values, such as courage and standing up for what is right.
The cultural shift towards "cool" has overshadowed the traditional ideals of being a man, as exemplified by the transition from the smart set to the cool idols like Frank Sinatra and James Dean. This shift, as noted by Michael Kelly, led to the devaluation of doing the right thing and being a good, upstanding person. Hemingway's works, despite appearances of cynicism towards honor and war, were actually an attempt to capture and modernize these old ideals. The current moral relativism and loss of clear-cut good and evil in society necessitate a return to these foundational values, which can be achieved by individuals embracing their courage and standing up for what is right.
Exploring Authenticity and Courage in Hemingway's Literature: Hemingway's works emphasize the importance of standing up to one's ideals, even in defeat, through tragic heroes and metaphors of bullfighting and hunting.
That Ernest Hemingway, through his literature, explored the concept of finding authenticity and courage in the face of adversity. He believed that every generation needs to create new myths to understand and evolve old ideas. Hemingway's works often feature tragic heroes who lose or die but maintain their dignity, emphasizing the importance of standing up to one's ideals even in the face of defeat. This theme can be seen in metaphors such as the bullfighter and the hunter. Hemingway's own life experiences, including his unhappy childhood, influenced his writing, which often portrayed characters struggling to find meaning and strength amidst hardships. Robert Cohen, a character in "The Sun Also Rises," serves as a contrast to Hemingway's code, embodying weakness and lack of resilience. Overall, Hemingway's works offer insights into the human condition, highlighting the importance of courage, authenticity, and resilience in the face of adversity.
Exploring Masculinity and the Present Moment: The Sun Also Rises delves into masculinity, immaturity, and the significance of living in the present, contrasting Robert's fixation on the past with Jake Barnes' encouragement to embrace the moment.
He's unable to commit to relationships, unable to let go of past disappointments, and unable to grow into his role as a man. He's fixated on his past glory days and unable to live fully in the present. His behavior is contrasted with Jake Barnes, the main character, who encourages Robert to live in the moment and find meaning in the present, rather than dwelling on the past. The novel also explores the theme of a religious pilgrimage, as the characters embark on a journey to the shrine of St. James in Spain. This journey serves as a metaphor for self-discovery and finding meaning in life. Overall, "The Sun Also Rises" offers a nuanced exploration of masculinity, immaturity, and the importance of living fully in the present.
Hemingway's writing influenced by Protestant upbringing and personal experiences: Hemingway's 'The Sun Also Rises' explores themes deeply rooted in his Protestant upbringing and personal experiences, including self-discovery and the Running of the Bulls in Pamplona.
Hemingway's writing, particularly in "The Sun Also Rises," was deeply influenced by his Protestant upbringing and his quest for self-discovery, rather than his later conversion to Catholicism. The pilgrimage in the novel was inspired by his own experiences and the teachings he learned as a child. Additionally, Hemingway's fascination with the Running of the Bulls in Pamplona, Spain, was a real-life event that he popularized through his writing. The festival, which combined religious and festive elements, grew in popularity during the 17th and 18th centuries and became a test of bravery and endurance for participants. Hemingway's exploration of these themes, rooted in his personal experiences and upbringing, continue to resonate with readers today.
Running of the Bulls: More Than Just a Dangerous Tradition: The Running of the Bulls in Pamplona is a transformative experience for Spanish youth, requiring preparation, patience, and a willingness to face mortality. A knowledgeable mentor is crucial for ensuring safety and understanding cultural significance.
The Running of the Bulls in Pamplona, Spain, is a deeply rooted tradition that has evolved over centuries. It's not just about running in front of charging bulls, but a rite of passage for Spanish youth. Tom Hemingway, who famously wrote about the experience, was initially shocked by the mature and intense atmosphere. For those interested in writing about or participating in the event, finding a knowledgeable mentor like Juan Macho is crucial for ensuring safety and understanding the cultural significance. The experience requires preparation, patience, and a willingness to face mortality. Runners must enter the street before the bulls and wait for them to arrive, and once the barriers close, there's no escape. The tradition carries a risk, but with proper guidance and respect for the event, it can be a transformative experience.
Rites of Passage: Challenging and Transforming Individuals: Rites of passage, like running with the bulls, test individuals' limits, instill respect for nature, and foster courage, maturity, and appreciation for life's complexity.
That rites of passage, such as running with the bulls in Spain, serve to challenge and transform individuals into mature adults. These experiences often involve a frightening ordeal that tests one's limits, followed by guidance and support in rebuilding and growing. The process instills respect for the natural world and a deep understanding of the importance of adhering to a code of conduct. Through these experiences, individuals develop courage, maturity, and a newfound appreciation for the power and complexity of life. The fact that women now participate in these rites of passage underscores their transformative and inclusive nature.
Respecting the rules of traditions: Traditions have deep-rooted rules and codes, disregarding them can lead to harm, and respecting them fosters growth and appreciation.
Traditions, even those that may seem barbaric to outsiders, often have deep-rooted rules and codes that must be respected. The Running of the Bulls in Spain is an example of this, with participants following a strict set of rules to ensure the safety of both the bulls and the runners. Breaking these rules can result in severe consequences, including physical harm. Furthermore, rights of passage are not a one-time event, but rather a continuous process of personal growth and development throughout one's life. Understanding and respecting these traditions and the rules that come with them can lead to a deeper appreciation and growth as individuals.
A deeper look into the meaning behind bullfighting: Bullfighting, rooted in history, symbolizes the circle of life and holds cultural significance for Spaniards, despite varying opinions on its brutality.
Traditions and cultural practices, like bullfighting, evolve over time and hold deeper meanings beyond their surface. Bullfighting, which originated from Roman times and developed in Spain, is not just a violent spectacle, but a tragic celebration of life. It's a reminder of the circle of life where predators and prey coexist. The bull, bred specifically for this purpose, is a symbol of strength and power. For some, it's a heroic act of bravery, while for others, it's an unnecessary display of cruelty. Regardless of personal opinions, it's essential to understand the history and significance behind cultural practices before judging them. Bullfighting is a part of Spanish heritage, and dismissing it without proper education can be disrespectful.
Bullfighting: A display of Spanish tradition and manliness: Bullfighting is a traditional Spanish practice that embodies respect for animals and a display of manliness, with strict codes of ethics ensuring a swift, clean death for the bull.
Bullfighting, as a traditional Spanish practice, embodies a deep respect for the animal and a display of Spanish manliness. The picadors weaken the bull, and the matador, in following a strict code of ethics, delivers a swift, clean death with his sword. Failure to do so results in public embarrassment and shame. This process, though it may be hard for outsiders to understand, is a visual reminder of our connection to the natural world and the consequences of our actions. In modern times, codes of honor are often viewed with skepticism and cynicism, as oversimplified or outdated concepts. However, the practice of bullfighting, with its long history and intricate rituals, continues to uphold these values in a visceral and public way.
Establish a personal code of honor: Create personal values based on past codes, align with modern values, guide actions, and make right decisions
While we may have lost the belief in heroic figures fighting for absolute good, it's essential for each individual to establish their personal code of honor. Codes of honor, such as those from the past like Bushido, should not be dismissed as simplistic or chauvinistic, but rather, we should learn from them and create our own codes that align with modern values. These codes will provide a foundation for our actions and help us make the right decisions when faced with challenging situations. Hemingway's literature, particularly "The Old Man and the Sea," reflects this idea of creating a new myth of manliness by looking to the past and transforming it for the present. This ideal is embodied in characters like Jake and the young man in the story, who demonstrate their values through their actions rather than just their words. By establishing our own codes, we can be the stand-up guys we aspire to be.
Embrace life's difficulties and learn from them: Learn to face life's challenges with courage and understanding to grow into the ideal version of oneself
Minitiere, through his book "This Will Make A Man Out Of You," encourages readers to embrace life's difficulties and learn from them to grow into the ideal version of themselves. He emphasizes the importance of standing up for oneself and taking responsibility for one's actions. Minitiere's work can be found on Amazon and Barnes & Noble, as well as on his website, frankminter.com, where he also writes a column for Forbes. To learn more about this topic, check out the show notes at aom.is/man-of-view. Remember, the path to manliness is not about following rules but about facing life's challenges with courage and understanding.
![[S1] John Cary: My Best Conversations with Men Happen While Running](https://www.podcastworld.io/podcast-images/creating-our-own-lives-h8yi4cec.webp)
