Logo
    Search

    52: What Math Models of Herding Cows Can Teach Us About Markets

    enOctober 28, 2016

    Podcast Summary

    • Understanding herding behavior in markets through cow dynamicsInvestors can learn from cow herding behavior to make informed decisions and navigate market trends effectively, as Principal Asset Management uses a 360-degree perspective to deliver local insights and global expertise.

      The behavior of cows in herds can provide insights into the dynamics of markets and investing. Principal Asset Management, as a real estate manager, uses a 360-degree perspective to deliver local insights and global expertise, helping identify the most compelling investing opportunities. This approach is similar to how cows in a herd follow each other's behavior, which is a common analogy for investors acting in markets. The mathematical model for the dynamics and synchronization of cows, as discussed in a recent paper, can shed light on herding behavior and its impact on markets. By understanding this behavior, investors can make more informed decisions and navigate market trends effectively. Principal Asset Management, CIT, and American Express offer various solutions to help businesses grow and adapt to market conditions. Investing involves risk, and it's essential to consider all available resources and insights to make informed decisions.

    • Understanding Herding Behavior in Markets: Insights from Animal HerdsHerding behavior, observed in animal herds, is also prevalent in financial markets. Experts in complex systems and nonlinear dynamics have studied this phenomenon in various contexts, revealing insights into how ideas spread and trends emerge through information flow and social influence.

      The concept of herding behavior, where individuals follow the actions of others, is prevalent in both animal herds and financial markets. This idea, which comes from observing how cows graze, can help us understand and model herding in markets. The authors of a recent paper on this topic, Jay Sun, Eric Bote, and Mason Porter, are experts in complex systems and nonlinear dynamics. They have studied herding behavior in various contexts, including animal herds, fish swarms, and human groups. By taking an abstract perspective and focusing on the underlying patterns of collective behavior, they have gained insights into how ideas spread and trends emerge in different systems. Their research sheds light on the role of information flow and social influence in shaping market dynamics.

    • Understanding herding behavior in cows through synchronization of needsResearch on cow herding behavior revealed that synchronization of needs like eating, digesting, and sleeping among cows leads to optimized production and potential well-being benefits. Interactions between cows play a crucial role in determining the extent of synchronization.

      The decision to focus on cows for a research project on herding behavior was a result of serendipitous circumstances and the expertise of a zoologist collaborator. The project, which began as an agent-based model, aimed to understand the synchronization of needs such as eating, digesting, and sleeping among cows, both in pens and in the wild. This synchronization not only helps protect cows from predators but also allows them to optimize their production and potentially increase their overall well-being. The researchers found that interactions between cows played a crucial role in determining the extent of synchronization. Although the research primarily focused on cow behavior, the term "coupling" in farming contexts refers to a completely different concept. The project's centerpiece was the cow's internal circadian rhythm, which includes the need to eat, digest, and sleep, and the benefits of synchronization extend to both natural and controlled environments. The researchers' work also explores the reasons behind this behavior, such as optimizing resilience to predators. Overall, the study sheds light on the complex interplay of individual needs and social behavior in herding animals like cows.

    • Cows in larger herds exhibit less synchrony in standing and sitting behaviorResearch shows that while smaller herds of cows tend to synchronize their behaviors, larger herds exhibit less synchrony. The degree of synchrony, not complete merging of behaviors, is the focus of mathematical models. External factors, such as weather conditions, can make it challenging to measure synchrony accurately.

      While cows in smaller herds tend to synchronize their standing and sitting behavior, larger herds exhibit less synchrony. This observation was made both through observation on farms and from mathematical models. However, it's important to note that complete synchrony is not required in these models, only the degree of synchrony. The term "coupled" in the context of these models refers to the interaction between the cows, not a complete merging of their behaviors. Measuring synchrony in animal behavior can be done by looking at the delay between when different animals stand up or sit down. The extent to which this synchrony comes from observing other animals or from individual desires is difficult to determine. Externalities, such as weather conditions, also play a significant role in cow behavior and can make it challenging to calculate synchrony within a model. Overall, understanding the complex interplay between individual behavior, group dynamics, and external factors in farming remains an ongoing research question.

    • Predicting Cow Behavior with TechnologyCows have distinct behaviors that can be monitored using technology, but increasing their density in a confined area can disrupt their natural rhythms and decrease synchrony among them.

      Cows exhibit unique behaviors that can be predicted and monitored using technology, such as the MooCall device that detects increased tail swishing before a cow gives birth. This product takes advantage of the fact that cows have distinct rhythms in their behavior, including walking, standing, eating, and lying down. Contrary to expectations, increasing the density of cows in a confined area does not necessarily lead to more synchronization or herding behavior. Instead, it can actually disrupt their natural rhythms and break the synchrony among them. From a mathematical perspective, this behavior can be modeled using traditional mathematical techniques, and the findings challenge common assumptions about how increasing interactions among animals would lead to more synchronization.

    • The Cowan-Lotka model explains how synchronization among entities decreases with more entities in a finite space.The Cowan-Lotka model shows that stronger interactions don't always lead to more synchronized behavior, highlighting the importance of considering interactions between entities.

      The extent of synchronization among interacting entities, such as cows or humans, may decrease when there are more entities in a finite space due to competition for resources or the pressure of too many entities. This concept, known as the Cowan-Lotka model, can be applied to other complex systems, including human behavior and investment patterns. The model, which uses mathematical equations to represent the switching between different states, shows that stronger interactions between entities do not always lead to more synchronized behavior. This research, which combines the study of cows and complex systems, highlights the importance of considering interactions between entities, rather than just focusing on individual dynamics. This perspective is particularly relevant in today's world, where the study of networks and complex systems emphasizes the emergence of effects from interactions that cannot be observed from individual components alone.

    • Understanding complex interactions in systems and predicting changes is challengingIdentifying early warning signs of changes in complex systems offers hope for predicting potential outcomes

      The interconnectedness of various components in complex systems, such as cat memes or financial markets, is crucial to understand their behavior. However, modeling these interactions is a challenging task. Before the financial crisis, attempts were made to model how one default could impact others using Gaussian copulas. The difficulty lies in distinguishing individual motion dynamics from interactions and predicting how these interactions might change in different environments. In the financial sector, this involves understanding the causality between different corporations. While tools from information theory have been used to analyze these interactions, predicting how they might change in real-world situations remains difficult. The hope lies in identifying early warning signs of changes in the system. In the context of herds and markets, a larger herd tends to lose synchronicity, and this can lead to unsustainable situations and potential catastrophic outcomes. For cats, herds may not want to synchronize in large groups due to the challenges of keeping them together and the communication issues between different ends of the herd. Additionally, there might be benefits to synchronizing on a certain scale but not in a larger one. Overall, understanding the complex interactions in various systems and predicting how they might change is a significant challenge, but identifying early warning signs offers some hope.

    • Understanding Market Dynamics through Herding Behavior and Media InfluenceResearch on herding behavior and media influence sheds light on complex market dynamics and investor behavior, potentially providing new insights into predicting market shifts and understanding network theories.

      The behavior of individuals in markets can be influenced significantly by the actions and perceptions of others, leading to phenomena like herding and market instability. This was discussed in relation to the example of cows herding, which can be compared to investors following trends in financial markets. The media plays a role in amplifying these behaviors by spreading information and creating a sense of panic or urgency. The researchers, Jay, Eric, and Mason, have been exploring this concept using a tool called causation entropy, and they believe it could provide new insights into understanding market dynamics and investor behavior. This research is important because it helps us better understand the complex network theories and connectivity that drive market behavior, and it highlights the ongoing challenge of predicting when and how markets may shift unexpectedly. Additionally, the concept of herding behavior breaking down in larger groups was also discussed in relation to market bubbles and the eventual collapse of seemingly unstoppable trends. Overall, the conversation emphasized the importance of studying the psychological and social factors that influence market behavior and the potential value of new research approaches like causation entropy.

    • Understanding market trend reversalsStaying informed about market trends and their potential impact on businesses is crucial, as shifts in demand or supply dynamics can lead to reversals.

      While predicting market trends with certainty is a challenging task, identifying the market's direction and understanding its potential implications can be valuable. The discussion touched upon the idea that once a market trend becomes established, there comes a point where the demand or supply dynamics may shift, leading to a potential reversal. This concept was compared to predicting the birth of a cow's calf, which, while possible with modern technology, is significantly more difficult when it comes to market trends. The conversation did not change the speaker's view on her cows, but it did highlight the importance of staying informed about market trends and their potential impact on businesses. Additionally, the speakers mentioned a new podcast, Money Stuff, which aims to provide insights on Wall Street finance and other related topics.

    Recent Episodes from Odd Lots

    Lots More With Neil Dutta on a Looming Fed Policy Error

    Lots More With Neil Dutta on a Looming Fed Policy Error

    Neil Dutta, the top economist over at Renaissance Macro, has generally been sunny and optimistic about the economy over the last four years or so. But now he's warning of a possible mistake by the Federal Reserve. In his view, the central bank is waiting too long to get confirmation that inflation is coming back to target. Meanwhile, unemployment is starting to creep up in a meaningful way. As he sees it, if you're still worried about upside risk to inflation at this point, you need to have a theory about where that inflation is going to come from — and it's really hard to come up with an answer for that right now, given the general downward momentum in hiring and the overall economy. In this episode of Lots More, we catch up with Neil to talk about the risk that the Fed will blow the soft landing.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 28, 2024

    The American Entrepreneurs Who First Opened The Chinese Market

    The American Entrepreneurs Who First Opened The Chinese Market

     From cars to toys to clothes, we're just used to seeing the label "Made In China" on all sorts of things. But how did China become a go-to destination for manufactured goods in the first place? Who actually recognized that there was a huge opportunity to tap the abundant, low-cost labor to sell goods to Western consumers? On this episode of the podcast we speak with Elizabeth Ingleson, a professor at the London School of Economics and the author of the book Made in China: When US-China Interests Converged to Transform Global Trade. Ingleson traces the roots of the US-China trade relationship to a handful of US entrepreneurs in the early 1970s who first went into the country and recognized its opportunity as an export powerhouse. We discuss who these individuals were, the obstacles they had to overcome, and how they reshaped the entire global economy.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 27, 2024

    Why Tom Lee Thinks We Could See S&P 15,000 by 2030

    Why Tom Lee Thinks We Could See S&P 15,000 by 2030

    The stock market has had a torrid run in 2024 despite the fact that interest rate cuts haven't materialized in the way people had expected at the start of the year. In fact, outside of a few blips here and there (like spring 2020), US stocks have been phenomenal performers for years. Tom Lee, the founder of Fundstrat and FS Insight has been bullish for a long time, having caught the correct side of this lengthy trend. On this episode, we speak to the former JPMorgan strategist about how he thinks about the market, what he sees happening right now in macro and demographic trends, and why he thinks it’s plausible that the market could roughly triple in the next six years.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 24, 2024

    CoreWeave's CSO on the Business of Building AI Datacenters

    CoreWeave's CSO on the Business of Building AI Datacenters

    Everyone knows that the AI boom is built upon the voracious consumption of chips (largely sold by Nvidia) and electricity. And while the legacy cloud operators, like Amazon or Microsoft, are in this space, the nature of the computing shift is opening up new space for new players in the market. One of the hottest companies is CoreWeave, a company backed in part by Nvidia, which has grown its datacenter business massively. So how does their business actually work? How do they get energy? Where do they locate operations? How are they financed? What's the difference between a cloud AI and a legacy cloud? On this episode, we speak with CoreWeave's Chief Strategy Officer Brian Venturo about what it takes to build out operations at this scale.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 21, 2024

    John Arnold on Why It's So Hard To Build Things in America

    John Arnold on Why It's So Hard To Build Things in America

    Virtually everyone, across the ideological spectrum, has the view right now that it's too hard to build things (or get things done generally) in America. New infrastructure is thwarted by red tape and permitting. New housing is thwarted by YIMBYism. Even something that doesn't require much new construction -- like NYC's attempt to impose congestion pricing -- is difficult to get done after years and years of wrangling. What is the core problem? And what can be done to address it? On this episode, we speak with John Arnold, who started his career as an energy trader at Enron, before going on to found a highly successful energy hedge fund. Now in his role as the co-founder of Arnold Ventures, he works on policy solutions to address these key bottlenecks. We discuss how he goes about philanthropy to affect policy change, the problems he's identified, and what solutions could be put in place to improve domestic development.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 20, 2024

    Evolving Money: Money Without Borders (Sponsored Content)

    Evolving Money: Money Without Borders (Sponsored Content)

    Throughout history, financial markets have struggled with the issue of borders. Borders create friction, add cost and cause headaches for anyone who wants to spend money across them. On top of that, various national currencies can be wildly unstable.

    Could a borderless, global currency ease friction and enhance financial inclusion and stability around the world? Cryptocurrencies offer an intriguing possible solution to money’s border problem. And a particular kind of cryptocurrency, called stablecoins, could become a powerful medium of exchange for international payments - and offer people around the world increased economic freedom.

    This episode is sponsored by Coinbase.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 18, 2024

    The Big Trade Underneath the Strangely Calm Surface of the S&P 500

    The Big Trade Underneath the Strangely Calm Surface of the S&P 500

    For much of this year, the S&P 500 has marched steadily higher while measures of stock market volatility, like the VIX, have stayed pretty low. But looking at the headline index only tells you part of the story. Beneath the surface of the S&P 500, individual stocks have been moving up and down a lot. And of course, traders have figured out a way to make money on the difference between the quiet overall index and all that volatility happening in individual stocks. This is the dispersion trade that's gotten quite a bit of attention in recent months. But figuring out exactly who's doing it and how pervasive it is isn't that easy. In this episode, we speak with Michael Purves, CEO and founder of Tallbacken Capital Advisors, and Josh Silva, managing partner and CIO at Passaic Partners, about this new volatility trade and what it means for the overall stock market.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 17, 2024

    What a 'Degen' Crypto Trader Really Does All Day

    What a 'Degen' Crypto Trader Really Does All Day

    A few lucky people have made generational wealth trading the ups and downs of the crypto market. And some finance professionals have shifted gears to focus primarily on the space. But what is it like to actually trade these coins day-to-day? How do people pick which ones to buy? How do they analyze the coins themselves? How do they get reliable information? And what is it like, emotionally, to trade such an infamously volatile asset? On this episode of the Odd Lots podcast, we speak with Julian Malinak. In his day job, Julian works in healthcare tech. But the rest of the time, he's looking on message boards for the next 100-bagger. At one point he had made enough to retire on. And then it all went poof. But he keeps grinding and trying to improve his craft. Julian — who we found on the Odd Lots Discord server — explains what he does all day, and how the market really works from a trading perspective. 

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 14, 2024

    How Indonesia and China Cornered the Nickel Market

    How Indonesia and China Cornered the Nickel Market

    There's been a huge change in the market for nickel, which goes into everything from electric vehicles to steel. Indonesia has grown to absolutely dominate production and now provides more than 55% of the world's supply. A lot of that is going to China, which has partnered with Indonesia to help grow its nickel industry at a phenomenal rate. Now, there are accusations that low-grade and low-priced Indonesian nickel is flooding the global market, to the detriment of other producers. Western miners like BHP and Anglo American have been shuttering their own nickel operations, and have written them down by billions of dollars in recent years. On this episode, we speak with Michael Widmer, head of metals research at Bank of America, about the sea change that's taken place in the world's nickel market and what it says about the green energy transition, as well as the scramble for other strategically important metals. We also talk about all those bullish calls on copper, and general volatility in the metals space.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 13, 2024

    Elon Musk Dominates Outer Space Like Nobody Has Before

    Elon Musk Dominates Outer Space Like Nobody Has Before

    The company that Elon Musk is most known for, obviously, is Tesla. It's been extraordinarily successful and made him one of the richest people in the world. But his true love may be SpaceX, the rocket company whose technology may one day be used in getting humans to Mars. But even if interplanetary trips are a long way off, there's no historical precedent for the sheer scale of the outer space dominance that Elon Musk has built out. Between his rockets and his satellite-based internet company Starlink, no one individual has ever completely dominated outer space this way. So where are these businesses going and how do they fit into the Elon empire? On this episode, we speak to three of our Bloomberg colleagues who have covered Musk and his businesses. First, we talk about the history and science of rockets with Bloomberg News reporter Ashlee Vance, the author of the book, When the Heavens Went on Sale: The Misfits and Geniuses Racing to Put Space Within Reach. Then we speak with Dana Hull and Max Chafkin, two of the hosts of Bloomberg's Elon Inc. podcast, about Musk's broader constellation of companies and how they all fit together.

    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    Odd Lots
    enJune 12, 2024

    Related Episodes

    002 Property Valuation: Art vs. Science

    002 Property Valuation: Art vs. Science

    Today, I would like to bring back an old discussion from my times as a student, on how art and science disciplines apply to property valuation. We will analyse the parts of the industry that relate to each discipline, and how they interact.

    What You Will Learn In This Episode:

    - What is considered art in property valuation, and what part is considered science

    - Why the uniqueness of some properties can only be understood from an art standpoint

    - The role of science in setting a value for a certain property

    Every piece of art is unique, and its artistic value will change depending on who is asked about it. Science is the complete opposite, where everything is measurable and comparable. But in property valuation, art and science are complementary, and they work together.   

    Resources:

    - My website: https://www.askrobco.com/ 

    - Twitter https://twitter.com/askrobco 

    - Instagram https://www.instagram.com/askrobco/ 

    - YouTube https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCmo02uW8LTXUhfiKB2oDlyA 

    - LinkedIn https://uk.linkedin.com/in/rob-cohen-125758172 

    356 - Skillfully Navigating Market Changes in Commercial Real Estate with Joe Killinger

    356 - Skillfully Navigating Market Changes in Commercial Real Estate with Joe Killinger

    Get a fresh perspective on the commercial real estate industry with successful broker Joe Killinger as we examine market trends, opportunities, and challenges, plus his top advice for investors. Dive into this episode and hear his wild story about getting a free store and learn why having the right insight at the right time is essential in real estate investing!

     

    Key takeaways to listen for

    • Expert outlook on the commercial real estate market
    • Factors influencing lease flexibility
    • Innovative ways to repurpose vacant shopping malls
    • The importance of mastering the fundamentals of real estate investing
    • What commercial real estate investment offers the most liquidity?

     

    Resources mentioned in this episode

     

    About Joe Killinger

    Joe has spent the last 30 years working in the real estate industry, honing his skills as an agent, investor, syndicator, founder, and operator of businesses and properties. He is personally responsible for and involved in marketing over 5,900 assets across the United States, resulting in over 900 million dollars in closed transactions. Moreover, he has launched and run businesses for multiple investors, founded and managed his own companies, and is currently an active investor in California and Texas.

     

    Connect with Joe

     

    Connect with Leigh

    Please subscribe to this podcast on iTunes or the Podcasts App on your phone, and never miss a beat from Leigh by visiting https://leighbrown.com. DM Leigh Brown on Instagram @ LeighThomasBrown.

    Subscribe to Leigh’s other podcast Real Estate From The Rooftops

     

    Sponsor

    Leigh Brown University – New On-Demand Training
    How to Dominate During This Recession!

    Enroll Now to get ahead of the curve and learn how to manage changing markets, the action steps for what to do, and most importantly, what to say so that you can secure listings, assist more buyers, and grow your business no matter what the market is doing.

    Link: http://dominatethisrecession.com

    SPACs, Stocks, and Being Indispensable ft. Andrew Ross Sorkin

    SPACs, Stocks, and Being Indispensable ft. Andrew Ross Sorkin
    Andrew Ross Sorkin joins Scott to discuss the state of play on SPACs, the markets, and the tech stocks. Andrew also shares how the pandemic has impacted his family life and work. Follow Andrew on Twitter, @andrewrsorkin. (16:23) Scott opens with his thoughts on why states shouldn’t get a bailout, CDC guidelines, Netflix testing out short-form video clips (9:23), and Twitter testing out commerce on the platform (13:17).  This Week’s Office Hours: whether Twitter should acquire Reddit (54:55), NFTs (57:16), and a litmus test for whether you should go get your MBA (61:26). Algebra of Happiness: A poem from a listener (65:48).   Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    The Downfall of a Real Estate Empire

    The Downfall of a Real Estate Empire
    Over the past four years, Jay Gajavelli built a real-estate empire using funds from small investors who wanted to make passive income. Last year, Gajavelli’s company owned more than 7,000 apartments in the Houston area. Now he’s at the center of one of the biggest commercial real-estate blowups in years. WSJ’s Will Parker details what happened and what it says about the housing market going forward. Further Reading: - A Housing Bust Comes for Thousands of Small-Time Investors  Further Listening: - How High Will Interest Rates Go?  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices