Logo

    Exclusions, black holes and dividing by zero

    enSeptember 04, 2024
    What was the main topic of the podcast episode?
    Summarise the key points discussed in the episode?
    Were there any notable quotes or insights from the speakers?
    Which popular books were mentioned in this episode?
    Were there any points particularly controversial or thought-provoking discussed in the episode?
    Were any current events or trending topics addressed in the episode?

    Podcast Summary

    • Special educational needs counting methodsDifferent counting methods and definitions led to a higher percentage of children identified as having special educational needs in Wales compared to England.

      The percentage of children in Wales with special educational needs, as reported in a headline, was found to be higher than in England due to different counting methods and definitions. The research in Wales counted children who had special educational needs identified at any point between starting school and doing their GCSEs, which resulted in a higher percentage compared to England where the research looked at the same educational history. However, it's important to note that the definition of special educational needs also varied, with some children only requiring additional support in the classroom for behavioral, emotional, or social difficulties. Additionally, Wales has since changed its system to include "additional learning needs," leading to a nearly 20% decrease in the number of children being identified.

    • Changes in education policies and pupil exclusionsThe new education system requires more individualized support for pupils with additional learning needs, altering financial support for schools. Exclusion rates for black pupils are currently lower than the average, but have risen for girls and younger students in secondary schools due to pandemic disruptions.

      There have been significant changes in education systems and policies, leading to shifts in pupil identification, funding, and exclusions. The new system requires more individualized support for pupils with additional learning needs, altering financial support for schools. Exam anxiety has been a concern, with reports suggesting a third of students were withdrawn from GCSE exams due to anxiety. However, this figure is likely an overestimation based on teacher surveys. Permanent exclusions have seen an increase to the highest recorded annual number, but this is not an all-time high when considering changes in data collection methods and under-reporting in older figures. The exclusion rates for black pupils are currently lower than the average, with Black Caribbean pupils having a higher exclusion rate than other groups. Exclusions have risen due in part to a bounce back from pandemic disruptions, with girls and younger age groups in secondary schools seeing significant growth in exclusion rates.

    • Public sector pay settlementsHigher-than-expected public sector pay settlements led to a £22 billion budget shortfall in the UK government, which could result in increased borrowing or spending cuts

      The UK government is facing a significant budget shortfall of approximately £22 billion, according to a recent audit. This shortfall is due to higher-than-expected public sector pay settlements, which the government had not fully accounted for in its budget. The implications of this shortfall are significant, as it could lead to increased borrowing or cuts in other areas of spending. This revelation comes after repeated warnings from the opposition during the election campaign about the need for transparency regarding the public finances. The size of the shortfall is not insignificant, as it represents a substantial portion of the government's annual spending. While it may not be a large number compared to the overall government budget, it is a larger amount than was previously anticipated, and it highlights the importance of accurate budgeting and transparency in government finance.

    • UK gov't unexpected spendingThe UK gov't has faced an unplanned £22bn overspend, primarily due to asylum and immigration costs, which has added to existing financial pressures

      The UK government has faced an unexpected £22 billion overspend in various areas, with a significant portion going towards asylum and immigration costs. This overspend, which includes unexpected increases in housing asylum seekers and railway funding, has been a recurring issue for the past few years, with the Home Office and Treasury collectively failing to budget adequately for these costs. The reasons for this under-budgeting are unclear and have been a subject of scrutiny by the Home Affairs Select Committee. The implications of this overspend are significant, as it adds to the financial pressures the government is already facing. Contrary to a viral claim on Twitter, there are not more Ghanaian nurses working in the NHS than in Ghana.

    • Ghanaian nurses recruitmentThe UK's recruitment of a large number of Ghanaian nurses raises concerns due to Ghana's low healthcare staffing and the need for accurate math education to prevent misconceptions

      There is a significant increase in the number of Ghanaian nurses coming to work in the UK each year, which has raised concerns due to Ghana's status on the World Health Organization's "red list" of countries whose healthcare staffing is already low and cannot afford to lose more healthcare workers. This rapid increase in recruitment, along with those from other countries like India and the Philippines, is necessary for the UK to meet its target of recruiting 50,000 additional nurses into the NHS. However, a viral Reddit post brought to light a common misconception in mathematics education, where a third-grade teacher incorrectly taught that one divided by zero equals zero. It is important to address such misconceptions in education to ensure accurate knowledge and understanding.

    • Division by ZeroMathematically, division by zero is undefined and results in contradictory concepts, but calculators may still provide answers. It's important to understand this concept to avoid potential errors and misunderstandings in mathematical calculations.

      Dividing by zero is an operation that doesn't have a meaningful answer in mathematics. This concept can be understood intuitively as trying to share a finite number of items among zero people, resulting in all items still being available. Mathematically, division by zero is undefined due to the lack of an inverse operation, making it impossible to determine the original value after the division. Despite calculators providing answers for such operations, mathematicians agree that it's not valid and should be avoided. This concept, which seems to contradict the foundational ideas of counting and division, can be frustrating but is an essential part of the mathematical system.

    • Human DevelopmentThe BBC Radio 4 series 'Child' explores the complexities of fetal development, childbirth, and toddler growth, shedding light on the importance of addressing challenges in maternity services for optimal human development.

      The BBC Radio 4 series, "Child," explores the fascinating journey of human development from fetus to toddler, shedding light on the intricacies of fetal development, the challenges of childbirth, and the remarkable feats of growth and learning in the first year of life. The series, presented by Tim Harford, delves into the politics and mechanics of birth, highlighting the importance of addressing the issues in our maternity services. By understanding this journey, we gain a deeper appreciation for the world around us. Listen to "Child" on BBC Sounds.

    Recent Episodes from More or Less: Behind the Stats

    Nate Silver: Do risk-takers run the world?

    Nate Silver: Do risk-takers run the world?

    Big stakes poker player and elections analyst Nate Silver is no stranger to a calculated risk.

    In his new book, On The Edge, he makes the case that people willing to take massive calculated risks are winning in the modern economy.

    Tim Harford talks to Nate about the mindset that’s driving hedge fund managers, crypto true-believers and silicon valley investors.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Producer: Beth Ashmead Latham Series producer: Tom Colls Production co-ordinator: Katie Morrison Sound mix: Nigel Appleton Editor: Richard Vadon

    More or Less: Behind the Stats
    enSeptember 14, 2024

    How long does it take to turn around an oil tanker?

    How long does it take to turn around an oil tanker?

    Do illegal migrants receive more in benefits than pensioners? Was Energy Secretary Ed Miliband right to celebrate a “record breaking” renewable energy auction? Is one divided by zero infinity? Why don’t we spend more on evidence that government spending works? And how long does it actually take to turn around an oil tanker?

    Tim Harford investigates some of the numbers in the news.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Charlotte McDonald Producers: Natasha Fernandes, Bethan Ashmead-Latham and Nathan Gower Series producer: Tom Colls Production co-ordinator: Katie Morrison Sound mix: Gareth Jones Editor: Richard Vadon

    More or Less: Behind the Stats
    enSeptember 11, 2024

    Who pays when trade wars heat up?

    Who pays when trade wars heat up?

    Donald Trump wants new tariffs on goods coming into the US, describing them as a tax on other countries. The Democrats are no stranger to trade tariffs themselves, with Joe Biden having added them to numerous goods coming into the US from China.

    We talk to Erica York from the Tax Foundation about how tariffs work and who ends up paying for them.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Producers: Kate Lamble and Beth Ashmead Latham Series producer: Tom Colls Production co-ordinator: Katie Morrison Sound mix: Steve Greenwood Editor: Richard Vadon

    More or Less: Behind the Stats
    enSeptember 07, 2024

    Exclusions, black holes and dividing by zero

    Exclusions, black holes and dividing by zero

    Do half of children in Wales have special educational needs? Are permanent exclusions at the highest ever level in England? Labour are talking about a £22bn black hole. Is that a new black hole in the finances? Are there more Ghanaian nurses in the UK than in Ghana? Can you divide one by zero?

    Tim Harford looks at some of the numbers in the news.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporters: Kate Lamble and Nathan Gower Producer: Beth Ashmead Latham Series producer: Tom Colls Production co-ordinator: Katie Morrison Sound mix: Andy Fell Editor: Richard Vadon

    More or Less: Behind the Stats
    enSeptember 04, 2024

    Where have Cuba’s people gone?

    Where have Cuba’s people gone?

    The Cuban government has announced that their population has fallen by 10% in two years – just days after a demographer on the Caribbean island suggested an even bigger fall.

    But which is the right number, and why are so many people leaving?

    We speak to Dr Emily Morris from University College London and Dr Jorge Duany from the Cuban Research Institute at Florida International University.

    Presenter: Kate Lamble Producer: Beth Ashmead Latham Series producer: Tom Colls Production co-ordinator: Katie Morrison Sound mix: Sue Maillot Editor: Richard Vadon

    Do we eat a credit card's worth of microplastic each week?

    Do we eat a credit card's worth of microplastic each week?

    The claim we all swallow 5.5 grams of microplastic each week – the same as the weight of a credit card – has been repeated by charities, newspapers and the World Economic Forum.

    But when you understand how this number was calculated, and the range of possible answers for the amount of plastic you eat, you might not want to repeat it yourself.

    Professor Jamie Woodward from the University of Manchester explains what’s what.

    Presenter: Kate Lamble Producer: Beth Ashmead Latham Researcher: Ajai Singh Series producer: Tom Colls Production co-ordinator: Katie Morrison Sound mix: Giles Aspen Editor: Richard Vadon

    Are companies making more money from their customers?

    Are companies making more money from their customers?

    Recent reports claimed the average global mark-up, the difference between the price of production and the price that product is sold for, rose from 7% in 1980 to 59% by 2020.

    So is this true? Are some companies choosing to charge us more than ever for their products?

    We investigate the accuracy of these claims, and which companies are responsible with the help of Jan Eeckhout a Professor of Economics at Pompeu Fabra University in Barcelona

    Presenter: Kate Lamble Producer: Beth Ashmead Latham Production co-ordinator: Katie Morrison Sound mix: Neil Churchill Editor: Richard Vadon

    Is planet Earth getting greener?

    Is planet Earth getting greener?

    Canadian psychologist and culture war commentator Jordan Peterson says planet Earth has got 20% greener in the last 20 years.

    But satellite data tells a different story.

    We investigate the correct number, with the help of Dr Chi Chen, from Rutgers University in the US.

    Presenter: Kate Lamble Series producer: Tom Colls Production co-ordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Giles Aspen Editor: Richard Fenton-Smith

    Does a language die every two weeks?

    Does a language die every two weeks?

    Researchers have catalogued 7,164 languages spoken around the world - some are used daily by billions. Half are spoken by less than 8000 people. The death of a language, when it’s no longer spoken as a first language by anyone living is a deeply significant moment in the cultural life of communities.

    Multiple sources including the UN and National Geographic magazine have claimed this happens every two weeks. But we have reasons to be suspicious about that statistic. Gary Simons, executive editor of the Ethnologue language catalogue, explains where this idea came from.

    Presenter: Kate Lamble Producer: Debbie Richford Series producer: Tom Colls Production co-ordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Nigel Appleton Editor: Richard Fenton-Smith

    Are women 14 times more likely to die in natural disasters?

    Are women 14 times more likely to die in natural disasters?

    The idea that women outnumber men by 14 to 1 as casualties of natural disasters has been repeated in newspapers and online for years - the UN have even used this statistic.

    But when you track down the source, the research behind this claim leaves much to be desired.

    Presenter: Kate Lamble Series producer: Tom Colls Production co-ordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Nigel Appleton Editor: Richard Fenton-Smith