Logo
    Search

    SNP Leadership: What we've learned so far

    enMarch 15, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • Companies and Politicians Prioritizing CustomersBurrow focuses on easy assembly, durable materials, and fast shipping. Blue Nile offers exquisite pearls, gemstones, and fast shipping for Mother's Day. Quince ensures ethical manufacturing and affordable prices. Kate Forbes appeals to the public, focusing on economic growth, while Hamza Yousuf's faith might influence SNP membership's vote.

      Both Burrow Furniture and Blue Nile prioritize their customers, offering high-quality products, convenient shopping experiences, and attractive discounts during sales. Burrow focuses on easy assembly, durable materials, and fast shipping for their modular seating. Blue Nile aims to make Mother's Day special with exquisite pearls, gemstones, and fast shipping options. Quince offers high-end goods at affordable prices, ensuring ethical and responsible manufacturing. The SNP leadership contest features Kate Forbes and Hamza Yousuf, with Kate Forbes appealing to the general public and focusing on economic growth if elected as First Minister. The SNP membership's average age may influence the impact of Kate Forbes' faith on the vote. Overall, these discussions highlight companies and politicians prioritizing customers and addressing their needs.

    • SNP Leadership Race: Forbes vs YousafBoth Kate Forbes and Humza Yousaf are taking distinct approaches in the SNP leadership race, with Forbes focusing on broader appeal and Yousaf targeting SNP members for victory.

      The Scottish National Party (SNP) leadership race between Kate Forbes and Humza Yousaf has seen both candidates crystalize their campaigns with distinct approaches. Kate Forbes is focusing on appealing to a broader audience in the country, while Hamza Yousaf is targeting the SNP members to become the leader. The strategies are different, with Hamza Yousaf emphasizing the importance of winning the SNP election and Kate Forbes trying to increase her popularity in the country to appeal to SMP members for independence. The demographics of the SNP membership remain unclear, adding an element of unpredictability to the outcome. The race underscores the importance of understanding the nuances of political campaigns and the importance of unexpected factors in electoral politics.

    • Scottish Conservatives face dilemma over SNP leader preferenceThe Scottish Conservatives grapple with choosing between Kate Forbes and Humza Yousaf as the next SNP leader, with potential implications for unionist sentiment and the political landscape in Scotland.

      The Scottish Conservative Party is facing internal divisions over who they prefer as the next SNP leader: Kate Forbes or Humza Yousaf. Unionists within the party believe that Forbes has the potential to turn soft unionists into nationalists, making independence a possibility. However, tactically, they believe that Yousaf is better for the Conservatives as he is less likely to create a potential split in the SNP. Conversely, those who prioritize conservative interests would rather have Forbes as leader due to her potential to create a split in the SNP. From a Labour perspective, they see either candidate as a win as both are better than Nicola Sturgeon for them. The SNP's own membership and self-awareness regarding the leadership contest is uncertain, with some reports suggesting hidden support for Forbes in rural areas. Ultimately, the outcome of the contest could have significant implications for the political landscape in Scotland.

    • SNP Faces Internal Turmoil Amid Leadership RaceThe SNP is experiencing internal division as two candidates vie for the position of First Minister, with some members fearing the consequences of a Forbes victory and others seeing her as the best choice for the party's future.

      The Scottish National Party (SNP) is currently experiencing internal turmoil as two candidates, Kate Forbes and Humza Yusuf, vie for the position of First Minister. The atmosphere within the party is tense, with some members and former cabinet ministers openly criticizing the current hierarchy and supporting Forbes. Others, however, have closed ranks around Yusuf, who currently enjoys the support of the cabinet and a large number of elected parliamentarians. The survival instinct of the party is driving this division, with some members fearing the potential consequences of a Forbes victory and others seeing her as the best choice for the future of the SNP. Regardless of the outcome, it is clear that the party will need to find a way to come together and move forward in order to maintain its position as the governing party in Scotland and continue its pursuit of independence. Figures like John Swinney and Stephen Flynn may play key roles in helping to facilitate this reconciliation.

    • SNP leaders' endorsement of Hamza YousufWhile Swinney's endorsement could sway some voters, the overall impact on the SNP leadership contest might not be substantial due to the tight race and uncertain Regan supporters' influence.

      The endorsement of Hamza Yousuf by senior figures in the Scottish National Party, including John Swinney, may not significantly shift the balance of the ongoing leadership contest. While Swinney's backing could sway some undecided voters, the overall impact might not be substantial given the tight race between Yousuf and Kate Forbes. Moreover, the potential impact of Ash Regan's supporters on the outcome remains uncertain. If Regan were not in the race, the dynamic between Yousuf and Forbes might look different, particularly economically, but it's a hypothetical scenario. Ultimately, the unity within the party, despite the apparent divisions, might prove more powerful than the differences between its candidates.

    • Political rivals' similarities and differencesThe possibility of bringing opposing candidates into the cabinet exists, but animosity and differing stances on key issues like gender recognition reform could pose challenges.

      Despite the apparent closeness of the political rivals Ash Regan and Kate Forbes in the ongoing campaign, the foundations of running a country, economy, and politics are not that dissimilar. The idea of bringing opposing candidates into the cabinet to heal internal party divisions is a possibility, but animosity between the candidates remains a significant factor. The gender recognition reform issue could pose a challenge if Hamza Yousaf wins and the Greens' top priority is met. The division between the candidates in the past was primarily due to a voting procedure in the parliament, which might not be a factor under the current terms. However, the candidates' stance on gender recognition reform might make it difficult for them to go along with the cabinet if the issue arises again.

    • SNP Leadership: Priorities beyond IndependenceWhile independence is the SNP membership's top priority, a new first minister should focus on devolution and other issues until there's strong public support for a referendum.

      While independence remains the top priority for the SNP membership, it's not necessarily the top priority for the public or even for all the SNP leadership candidates. Hamza Yousuf has made it clear that it is his top priority, but realistically, an independence referendum is not imminent due to a lack of public support. The SNP leadership candidates are appealing to different audiences, with Hamza Yousuf focusing on the membership, and Kate Forbes and Ash Regan reaching out to a broader audience. After the membership election, it would be wise for the new first minister to reset expectations and focus on devolution and other issues until there is a sustained period of strong support for independence in the polls.

    • Competent government and economic platform needed for Scottish independenceTo gain public support for Scottish independence, the SNP must learn from past mistakes, provide competent governance, and present a clear economic vision.

      Gaining public support for Scottish independence will require competent government and a credible economic platform, which will take time. The Scottish Tory party's recent letter to SNP leadership candidate Kate Forbes, asking for permission to use her criticisms of the SNP's record in government, highlights the importance of honesty and competence in politics. The Scottish Tories are currently enjoying the negative attention being directed towards their rivals, but their future prospects are uncertain. The key to success for the SNP will be to learn from past mistakes, build public support through competent governance, and present a clear and compelling economic vision for an independent Scotland.

    • Scottish Tory vote decreases due to Labour's perceived election winThe Scottish Tory vote is decreasing due to the belief that Labour will win the UK general election, but Kate Forbes' centrist economics efforts may not help her. SNP's calls for an election have changed, and the timing of both UK and Holyrood elections remains uncertain.

      The Scottish Tory vote has significantly decreased due to the perception that the Labour Party is more likely to win the upcoming UK general election. The speaker also noted that Kate Forbes, the Scottish Conservative Finance Secretary, has made strides in promoting centrist economics, but this perception may not be beneficial for her as some view it as voting for a Tory in disguise. The speaker also acknowledged the possibility of a surprise comeback for the Conservatives, as they have a history of winning elections against the odds. The discussion also touched upon the potential timing of the UK general election and a possible snap Holyrood election in Scotland. A lesson from politics mentioned was to be careful what one wishes for, as the SNP's calls for an election when the Tories were frequently changing prime ministers have now changed to opposition to an election with the SNP in power.

    • Political dynamics and unpredictabilityBe cautious when criticizing others, as you may face similar situations. Scotland's unique political system, potential implications of elections, and respecting democratic processes are crucial.

      Politics can be unpredictable, and individuals should be cautious when criticizing others' actions, as they may find themselves in similar situations. The discussion also highlighted the unique aspects of Scotland's political system, where the First Minister is elected by MSPs, and the potential implications of a snap election or a Kate Forbes win for the Scottish National Party (SNP) and the Green Party. The importance of respecting democratic processes and the potential risks of party members not following their verdict were also emphasized. Additionally, the possibility of politicians using their potential to be elected as a means to persuade voters was mentioned. Overall, the conversation underscored the complexities and nuances of political dynamics and the importance of understanding the context and implications of various scenarios.

    • SNP Leadership Contest: Final Weeks of CampaigningCandidates need to remain focused and deliver messages effectively to win over voters during the final weeks of the SNP Leadership Contest, while avoiding controversial statements or signs of being rattled.

      The ongoing SNP leadership contest is heating up, with candidates vying for news lines and trying to gain an edge. However, making controversial statements or revealing signs of being rattled could backfire in the heat of the contest. The ballot is currently open for SNP members to vote, and the result is expected to be announced as soon as possible after the closing date on March 27th. There are still a couple of weeks of campaigning left, and much more to discuss in the coming days. The survival instinct plays a crucial role in the contest, and candidates need to be careful not to reveal signs of being unsettled. It's important for them to remain focused and deliver their messages effectively to win over voters. Overall, the contest is expected to be closely watched and fiercely contested, with every news line potentially making a big impact.

    Recent Episodes from Holyrood Sources

    To Bet Or Not To Bet

    To Bet Or Not To Bet

    Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer says “the culture of politics" needs to change in light of the investigations into allegations of gambling on the general election from both Conservative and Labour figures. Calum, Geoff, Andy and Cat Headley discuss what can be done to address the relationship between politics and gambling, and whether anything should be done at all. 


    Plus, if IndyRef2 becomes a fading prospect, what is the point of the Scottish Conservatives? Who's had a good election campaign? And who's had a bad one? All in today's episode. 


    This episode is sponsored by Port of Aberdeen. Find out more at https://www.portofaberdeen.co.uk/

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 26, 2024

    Manifestos, Scottish Tories and should polling stop?

    Manifestos, Scottish Tories and should polling stop?
    We discuss the recent launch of the SNP manifesto for the upcoming general election. We explore the purpose of a manifesto in a general election and the tactics at play. Plus, we discuss the potential impact of the polls on the outcome of the election and the future of the Scottish Conservative Party. We take your questions on the achievements of the SNP at Westminster and the possibility of a leadership contest within the Scottish Conservatives.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 20, 2024

    Growing Scotland's Economy: Holyrood Sources Live

    Growing Scotland's Economy: Holyrood Sources Live

    We're diving deep into the various economic challenges and opportunities that lie ahead for Scotland.


    With:

    Kate Forbes MSP (SNP), Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Gaelic.

    Murdo Fraser MSP (Conservative), Shadow Cabinet Secretary for Business, Economic Growth and Tourism.

    Michael Marra MSP (Labour), Shadow Cabinet Secretary for Finance.

    Willie Rennie MSP (Liberal Democrat), Spokesperson for Education, Economy and Communities.


    We'll be discussing key concerns raised by investors regarding infrastructure projects, planning, and the general business environment. Plus, we'll address the ambiguous terminology often used in policy-making, like the phrases "wellbeing economy" and "startup," which can hinder real progress. Our discussion today will also cover persistent issues of poverty and social mobility, the critical state of Scotland's education sector, the impact of Brexit on skilled workers, and the urgent need for immigration policies that support economic growth. We delve into the energy sector, focusing on offshore wind development, the fiscal constraints facing green prosperity plans, and the importance of a just transition from oil and gas to renewables. Moreover, we'll explore the impact of tax policies on the economy and public services, highlighting the need for a reevaluation of the taxation system to foster growth and retain talent.


    Holyrood Sources is sponsored by Port of Aberdeen, find out more at https://www.portofaberdeen.co.uk/


    This special episode is brought to you with our delivery partners, Scottish Financial Enterprise and in association with EY.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 19, 2024

    The SNP/Labour Poll Gap Closes...with Emily Gray

    The SNP/Labour Poll Gap Closes...with Emily Gray

    Ipsos’ first Scotland poll since the General Election indicates the SNP and Labour in Scotland share 36% of the country's voting intention. Managing Director of Ipsos in Scotland, Emily Gray, joins the podcast to discuss what it means. Plus, after predicting it would happen, Calum, Andy and Geoff assess what next for the Scottish Conservatives after Douglas Ross announced he would stand down as leader.


    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 12, 2024

    Douglas Ross U-Turns and will run to be an MP

    Douglas Ross U-Turns and will run to be an MP
    Douglas Ross has U-turned on a pledge to quit Westminster to focus on leading the Scottish Conservatives at Holyrood and will once again stand as a candidate at the general election. He will replace David Duguid, who was sacked last night as the candidate for Aberdeenshire North & Moray East because he suffered a serious spinal injury.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 06, 2024

    The Leaders Debate... We Discuss

    The Leaders Debate... We Discuss
    Calum, Geoff and Andy are joined by former Labour candidate Cat Headley to pick apart the key moments from last night's first television debate between Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer. There was a lot of back and forth, and interrupting, but what cut through? Plus, Nigel Farage is back - so what does that mean for the Conservatives, or for the future of the of the Right of politics?

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 05, 2024

    Deputy Leaders analyse the debates and campaign

    Deputy Leaders analyse the debates and campaign

    The podcast episode features post-debate analysis with the deputy leaders of Scottish political parties.


    Chapters

    5:05 - Jackie Baillie (Labour)

    The discussion covers the recent debate, party strategies, and key messages. It also delves into the topic of GB Energy and its potential impact on the energy sector. The conversation concludes with a discussion on Keir Starmer's U-turn on Diane Abbott's candidacy.


    23:02 - Kate Forbes (Deputy First Minister, SNP)

    The conversation covers party positioning, funding, oil and gas, campaign strategies, the SNP's election prospects, and EU funding. The discussion also delves into the SNP's economic policies, alliances with other parties, and the implications of Michael Matheson MSP maintaining the support of the party.


    49:55 - Meghan Gallacher (Conservative)

    The discussion delves into the performance of Douglas Ross, the Scottish Conservative Party's approach to campaign issues, and the impact of UK politics on the Scottish election. The conversation also explores the role of Rishi Sunak and the timing of the general election.


    1:05:17 - Wendy Chamberlain (Liberal Democrat)

    Wendy Chamberlain from the Liberal Democrats discusses the recent TV debate, the party's stance on Brexit, and their strategy for the upcoming election. The conversation also delves into the relevance of the Liberal Democrats in the current political landscape and their approach to environmental issues.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Holyrood Sources
    enJune 04, 2024

    Election Bulletin 1: What You Might Have Missed

    Election Bulletin 1: What You Might Have Missed
    Our first (maybe last, if you don't like it) Election Bulletin to catch you up on events from the week including: Michael Matheson, Diane Abbott, policy announcements and TikToks. Plus, Tales from the Campaign Trail where some of our journalist friends drop in to let us know how they're getting on. And we tell you what's on the agenda today.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Holyrood Sources
    enMay 31, 2024

    Polls, Diane Abbott and Campaigning Tales... with Allan Faulds

    Polls, Diane Abbott and Campaigning Tales... with Allan Faulds
    Ballot Box's Allan Faulds and former Labour Scottish Parliamentary candidate Cat Headley join Calum, Geoff and Andy to pick apart what new polling, the treatment of Dianne Abbott by the Labour party and also reflect on some of their favourite (or not-so-favourite) memories of being on the campaign trail.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    Holyrood Sources
    enMay 29, 2024

    Related Episodes

    Opposition then and now...with Ruth Davidson

    Opposition then and now...with Ruth Davidson

    Ruth Davidson, former leader of the Scottish Conservative party joins Calum, Geoff and Andy. She discusses the sympathy she feels for Humza Yousaf given the ongoing SNP crisis. Geoff and Andy say the new First Minister's programme for government is getting lost as the crisis around the SNP continues. Ruth reminisces about preparing for First Minister's Questions - she describes the differing styles of Nicola Sturgeon and Alex Salmond. She discusses the future of the Scottish Parliament, her memories of the independence referendum in 2014...and a lot more besides.


    Recorded Tuesday 18th April.

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Labour and SNP Draw Level

    Labour and SNP Draw Level
    New polling by Survation for True North (Geoff's Strategic Advisory firm) is out - how does it compare to what Humza Yousaf told us on last week's live podcast? We listen back to some of his answers and compare them to the polling which suggests the SNP and Labour are neck-and-neck on seat projections at the general election. Plus, we reveal the details of Geoff and Andy's election bets; and answer some of your questions. Also we look at Sir Tom Hunter's calls for changes on tax - does it feed into current political conversation in Scotland? 

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    What Humza Yousaf means for the SNP, Scottish independence and Labour

    What Humza Yousaf means for the SNP, Scottish independence and Labour

    Humza Yousaf is the new leader of the SNP after beating his closest rival, Kate Forbes, by 52 per cent to 48 per cent in the final round of the party’s leadership election.


    He’s the continuity candidate, but is continuity enough to keep the SNP in power in Holyrood and dominant in Scottish Westminster seats as it continues to push for independence?


    Anoosh Chakelian is joined by Chris Deerin, Scotland editor, to discuss the result, the bruising campaign and why Labour might be the happiest party north of the border right now.


    If you have a question for You Ask Us go to newstatesman.com/youaskus



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.


    Big Announcement + Scottish Labour... with Jim Murphy

    Big Announcement + Scottish Labour... with Jim Murphy

    We have a massive announcement for you.


    Plus, we preview Scottish Labour Party conference. We're joined by Jim Murphy, former leader of the Scottish Labour Party, who discusses his work advising candidates in elections around the world and navigating political risk. He also addresses the issue of antisemitism in British and Scottish politics and the recent suspension of Labour Party parliamentary candidates. The conversation touches on the relationship between Anas Sarwar and Keir Starmer, the impact of Labour Party policies on the oil and gas industry, and the importance of energy security and global security. Finally, Murphy reflects on the 25th anniversary of the Scottish Parliament and the need for improvement in addressing generational disadvantage.


    In association with the Royal Bank of Scotland.


    Click holyroodsources.com/live


    For a full list of candidates in the Rochdale by-election, click here:

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-68250468

    Become a member at https://plus.acast.com/s/holyroodsources.



    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.