Logo
    Search

    The Double-Edged Sword of the "Shark Tank Effect" with Club Penguin Cofounder Lane Merrifield

    enNovember 30, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • Monetizing existing assets: Airbnb and freemium business modelsConsider renting out unused spaces or offering freemium services to generate income with minimal startup costs. Successful examples include Airbnb and Club Penguin.

      Monetizing what you already have, such as a spare room, can be an easy and effective side hustle, like becoming an Airbnb host. This was emphasized by the speaker, who shared her experience of writing in remote cabins but also renting out her house on Airbnb to generate income. She encouraged new entrepreneurs to consider this option, as it doesn't require significant startup costs. Additionally, the conversation with Lane Merrifield, the co-founder of Club Penguin, provided insights into the success of a freemium business model, where a core product is offered for free but certain features are monetized. Club Penguin's approach to monetization was intentional, with chat being the most expensive feature, which was kept free to ensure accessibility for all users. Overall, the discussion highlighted the importance of capital efficiency, focus, and providing valuable free offerings to attract and retain customers.

    • Considering the right business model for your product and audienceWhen starting a business, carefully evaluate various business models to ensure a sustainable revenue stream and positive user experience. Initial resistance to subscription models has given way to their popularity due to recurring revenue and ad-free experiences.

      When starting a business, it's important to consider the pros and cons of various business models based on the unique aspects of your product and audience. The speakers in this discussion started Club Penguin with a premium model, monetizing through annual subscriptions, due to the need for recurring revenue to support their constant content creation and the desire to provide an ad-free experience for their young user base. They've seen the evolution of business models, from the initial resistance to subscriptions to the current normalization and popularity of subscription services. As an entrepreneur, it's essential to think beyond what will make the most money initially and focus on creating a win-win situation for both the business and its customers.

    • Putting user experience first leads to financial successDeliberately prioritizing user satisfaction over revenue can contribute to long-term financial growth. Club Penguin, an ad-free platform, became profitable within three months and had a peak ARR of over $150 million by focusing on user experience and growth organically.

      Putting user experience and satisfaction above revenue can lead to financial success in the long run. The founders of Club Penguin made a deliberate decision to keep their platform ad-free and accessible to all, even if it meant cutting off a revenue stream. This decision pleased their decision-makers and ultimately contributed to the platform's financial growth. They also chose to launch on the web initially and later transitioned to the app store, avoiding being hypocritical about providing a safe online space for all kids. Club Penguin was profitable within three months of launch and had an annual recurring revenue (ARR) of over $150 million at its peak. Despite the success, the founders were cautious about taking on venture capital (VC) funding, recognizing that it may not always be the best fit for every company. They believed that focusing on user experience and growth organically could lead to greater success.

    • The Shark Tank effect and its impact on founders' long-term wealthPressure to grow into a unicorn can lead to financial instability, loss of control, and less founder wealth despite impressive exit numbers. Focusing on profitability and sustainable growth can lead to better financial security and a balanced life.

      The pressure to grow a company into a unicorn, or a billion-dollar business, can sometimes lead to unrealistic expectations, financial instability, and even loss of control for founders. The constant need to secure larger funding rounds and meet ever-increasing valuations can result in founders giving away more equity than they intended, leaving them with less financial reward despite impressive exit numbers. This phenomenon, often compared to the Shark Tank effect, can be detrimental to founders' long-term wealth and the sustainability of their businesses. Instead, focusing on building a profitable lifestyle business or maintaining a reasonable growth pace can lead to more financial security and a better balance between personal and professional goals. It's crucial for founders to have open conversations about the financial realities of their businesses and the potential consequences of accepting large investments.

    • Balancing stakeholders while accepting investmentAccepting investment brings new responsibilities and potential focus shifts, requiring entrepreneurs to prioritize customers and maintain mission while managing stakeholders

      While accepting external investment can provide necessary resources for business growth, it also comes with new responsibilities and sources of anxiety. Entrepreneurs should remember that the investors and board members are not their only bosses; their ultimate responsibility lies with their customers. Accepting investment can lead to a shift in focus, potentially causing neglect of the very people who made the business successful. Additionally, entrepreneurs must be aware of the potential for poor decision-making under the pressure of answering to multiple stakeholders. It's crucial to strike a balance between managing up and staying true to the mission and the needs of the customers.

    • Founders' customer-centric approach led to Club Penguin's successThe founders prioritized customers over personal financial gain and opportunities, leading to a successful and profitable business. They hired top talent and discovered new revenue streams.

      Staying focused on the needs of the customers, in this case kids and their parents, was crucial for the success of Club Penguin. The founders made significant personal financial sacrifices, including taking out lines of credit on their homes, to ensure they could fully dedicate themselves to their business. They also adopted a mindset of prioritizing their customers above all else, even turning down opportunities that didn't directly benefit them. This customer-centric approach helped them create a successful and profitable business. Additionally, they utilized resources like LinkedIn jobs for hiring top talent, and discovered a potential revenue stream through hosting on Airbnb.

    • Monetizing physical and digital assetsExploring ways to monetize and interconnect physical and digital assets can lead to financial benefits and enhanced user experiences.

      Monetizing what you own, whether it's a physical space or virtual items, can provide financial benefits and open up new opportunities. The speaker shared her experience of hosting on Airbnb and how it helps offset the cost of her travels. In the gaming world, there were examples of earning digital coins through jobs and unlocking more content with those coins. This concept can be compared to modern cryptocurrencies and NFTs. Another intriguing idea discussed was interconnecting physical and digital worlds, allowing users to unlock content across platforms. The speaker's belief in this interconnectedness led to patents for connecting books, magazines, and games to the digital world. These ideas, though not new, paved the way for the current trend of transmedia or cloud entertainment. Overall, the discussion emphasizes the potential of monetizing and interconnecting physical and digital assets for enhanced user experience and financial gain.

    • Navigating challenges in family and teen focused businessesUnderstand unique challenges, communicate with audience, turn ideas into reality, implement parental controls, and prioritize children's well-being.

      Creating a successful business, especially in the family or teen focused sector, requires a deep understanding of the unique challenges and regulations involved. The speakers in this discussion, who founded Penguin Kids, emphasized the importance of maintaining open communication with their audience, turning their ideas into reality, and even implementing parental controls to limit screen time. They also highlighted the complexity of dealing with laws and regulations, such as COPPA, that are designed to protect children's privacy. Despite these challenges, they saw themselves as stewards of children's imagination and were committed to making a magical experience for kids. They didn't shy away from being the "bad guy" by implementing parental controls and limiting screen time, but instead saw it as a way to prioritize the well-being of their young audience. Entrepreneurs entering this sector should be prepared for the added complexity and regulations, but also for the reward of making a positive impact on children's lives.

    • Navigating Regulations and Building a Strong Team in Kids' EntertainmentUnderstand regulations, hire experienced employees, negotiate with industry giants, stay passionate and open-minded.

      Starting a business in the kids' entertainment industry requires a deep understanding of regulations and policies, and having experienced employees who can help navigate these complexities. The speaker, who started Club Penguin, emphasized the importance of knowing your weak spots and having a strong team. He shared his experience of negotiating with Disney, which seemed impossible when he was growing up in Southern California but ultimately led to a successful partnership. He advised that while it's essential to be passionate about the company and culture, it's also crucial to be open-minded and learn from impressive people, even if they are industry legends like Steve Jobs. The speaker's anecdotes show that the thrill of working with industry giants never fades, but it's essential to remember that they are human and can offer valuable insights.

    • Sharing experiences and lessons learned can provide valuable insights for entrepreneursDiscussing regrets and challenges can inspire entrepreneurs to overcome obstacles, consider alternative funding methods, and build stronger businesses.

      Everyone, including successful entrepreneurs and industry experts, faces fears, challenges, and regrets. It's essential to remember that people are not perfect and have their own struggles. When coaching entrepreneurs, discussing relevant experiences, including regrets and lessons learned, can provide valuable insights. The current economic climate may make fundraising more challenging, but it also encourages entrepreneurs to consider alternative funding methods, such as savings, partnerships, or bootstrapping. Being capital efficient and focusing on creating a viable product can help entrepreneurs save time and resources, ultimately leading to a stronger business foundation.

    • Creatively structuring deals with friends and familyFocus on long-term benefits by setting up trusts or investment vehicles, prioritize building a great product and taking care of stakeholders, and consider the economic climate when starting a business or investing.

      When it comes to raising funds from friends and family, it's essential to find creative ways to structure the deals that go beyond just focusing on financial returns. Instead, consider setting up trusts or investment vehicles that can benefit both parties in the long term. This not only reduces the pressure to deliver immediate capital gains but also allows for the creation of a lasting legacy. Additionally, it's crucial to remember that not every investment opportunity needs to be a high-stakes, high-growth proposition. Instead, focusing on building a great product, taking care of customers, and employees should be the priority. When it comes to starting a business or angel investing, consider the strengths and weaknesses of the opportunity, as well as the potential threats and opportunities in the current economic climate. Remember, the goal is to create sustainable value for all parties involved.

    • Explore creative ways to be capital efficientEntrepreneurs can foster long-term relationships and turn capital constraints into opportunities by partnering or bartering with other companies

      Entrepreneurs facing capital constraints should explore creative ways to be more capital efficient. This could involve partnering or bartering with other companies to access resources or distribution, rather than relying solely on traditional funding methods. Such arrangements can lead to mutually beneficial outcomes and foster long-term relationships. The speaker's experience with Club Penguin and Miniclip is a testament to the potential success of such collaborations. By thinking outside the box and embracing the spirit of barter and negotiation, entrepreneurs can turn perceived challenges into opportunities and ultimately grow their businesses.

    Recent Episodes from Money Rehab with Nicole Lapin

    Step-by-Step Guide for Making Your First Investment

    Step-by-Step Guide for Making Your First Investment
    Nicole's DMs are open for questions, and the #1 question she gets isn't what to invest in... but how to invest. Today, she takes you through making your first investment, step-by-step, and leaves no stone unturned. If you’re looking for a simple, yet sophisticated investing experience, go to Public.com/moneyrehab All investing involves the risk of loss, including loss of principal. Brokerage services for US-listed, registered securities, options and bonds in a self-directed account are offered by Public Investing, Inc., member FINRA & SIPC. Public Investing offers a High-Yield Cash Account where funds from this account are automatically deposited into partner banks where they earn interest and are eligible for FDIC insurance; Public Investing is not a bank. Brokerage services for alternative assets are offered by Dalmore Group, LLC, member FINRA & SIPC. Brokerage services for treasury accounts offering 6-month T-Bills are offered by Jiko Securities, Inc., member FINRA & SIPC. Banking services are offered by Jiko Bank, a division of Mid-Central National Bank. Securities investments: Not FDIC Insured; No Bank Guarantee; May Lose Value.  Brokerage services for Regulation A securities are offered through Dalmore Group, LLC, member FINRA & SIPC. Risks at public.com/disclosures/alts-risk-and-conflict-of-interest-disclosure See public.com/#disclosures-main for more information.

    How To Pick the Personal Loan That's Right For You

    How To Pick the Personal Loan That's Right For You
    Personal loans can be a lifeline in times of need. However, not all personal loans are created equal. Today, Nicole unpacks six common types of personal loans, the benefits and risks, and helps you understand which one might be the best for you and your financial picture. Want to estimate how long it would take you to pay off your debt? Use this debt repayment calculator: https://www.creditkarma.com/calculators/credit-cards/debt-repayment All investing involves the risk of loss, including loss of principal. Brokerage services for US-listed, registered securities, options and bonds in a self-directed account are offered by Public Investing, Inc., member FINRA & SIPC. Public Investing offers a High-Yield Cash Account where funds from this account are automatically deposited into partner banks where they earn interest and are eligible for FDIC insurance; Public Investing is not a bank. Brokerage services for alternative assets are offered by Dalmore Group, LLC, member FINRA & SIPC. Brokerage services for treasury accounts offering 6-month T-Bills are offered by Jiko Securities, Inc., member FINRA & SIPC. Banking services are offered by Jiko Bank, a division of Mid-Central National Bank. Securities investments: Not FDIC Insured; No Bank Guarantee; May Lose Value.  Brokerage services for Regulation A securities are offered through Dalmore Group, LLC, member FINRA & SIPC. Risks at public.com/disclosures/alts-risk-and-conflict-of-interest-disclosure See public.com/#disclosures-main for more information.

    Tips for Acing a Grant Application and Getting People To Care About Financial Literacy with Jailin Griffiths (Global Head of Purpose at Nasdaq) and Three Grant Winners

    Tips for Acing a Grant Application and Getting People To Care About Financial Literacy with Jailin Griffiths (Global Head of Purpose at Nasdaq) and Three Grant Winners
    Today, you’re going to get tips on investing, building generational wealth, teaching kids about financial literacy and applying for grants— and you’re going to hear this advice from three stellar recipients of the Nasdaq Foundation's Quarterly Grant Program. But first, Nicole sits down with Jailan Griffiths, the Global Head of Purpose for Nasdaq, to talk about the work Nasdaq is doing to further financial literacy, and the voice all companies should be listening to when shaping their mission (spoiler alert: it's their employees!). Read more about Nasdaq’s purpose-driven work, including the grant program, here: https://www.nasdaq.com/nasdaq-foundation  Check out the report Jailin mentions around their New Investor Initiative called Transforming Investor Identity, here: https://www.nasdaq.com/new-investor-initiative. Learn more about Judy Herbst & Savvy Ladies here: https://www.savvyladies.org/ Learn more about Sarah Dieleman Perry & Neighborhood Allies here: https://neighborhoodallies.org/  Learn more about Gayle Villani & GO Project here: https://www.goprojectnyc.org/

    Encore: Nicole Negotiates Her Rent!

    Encore: Nicole Negotiates Her Rent!
    Originally aired April 19, 2022. Money Rehabbers want to know: can you negotiate your rent after signing a lease? Be a fly on the wall as Nicole negotiates her rent with her landlord! Can Nicole get a better deal? You’ll have to tune in to find out!

    Related Episodes

    Kathleen Eisenhardt (Stanford) - Strategy for New Companies

    Kathleen Eisenhardt (Stanford) - Strategy for New Companies

    Kathleen Eisenhardt is the Stanford W. Ascherman M.D. Professor in the Stanford School of Engineering. She is also a faculty member with STVP, the Stanford Engineering Entrepreneurship Center, and the Stanford Digital Economy Lab. Among the most widely cited entrepreneurship scholars in the world, Eisenhardt is the author of over 100 articles and several books, most recently (with Don Sull), “Simple Rules: How to Survive in a Complex World.” In this presentation, Eisenhardt shares strategies for founders of new companies in new and disrupted markets, providing case studies from her extensive research.


    —-----------------------------------

    Stanford eCorner content is produced by the Stanford Technology Ventures Program. At STVP, we empower aspiring entrepreneurs to become global citizens who create and scale responsible innovations.


    CONNECT WITH US

    Twitter: https://twitter.com/ECorner 

    LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/stanfordtechnologyventuresprogram/ 

    Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/StanfordTechnologyVenturesProgram/ 

    YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/ecorner 


    LEARN MORE

    eCorner Website: https://ecorner.stanford.edu/

    STVP Website: https://stvp.stanford.edu/


    Support our mission of providing students and educators around the world with free access to Stanford University’s network of entrepreneurial thought leaders: https://ecorner.stanford.edu/give.



    Turning Your Side Hustle Into a Multimillion Dollar Business with Nely Galán

    Turning Your Side Hustle Into a Multimillion Dollar Business with Nely Galán
    Nicole welcomes the newest member of the Money News Network podcast fam, "Money Maker | Mi Mundo Rico" with Nely Galán. Money Maker is the podcast for everyone with untapped greatness who just needs the tools to take flight. New York Times bestselling author and business mogul Nely Galán brings her hard-won business advice and interviews with other self-made gurus ready to pass the baton to the next success story. With the goal of reaching listeners who have traditionally been denied a seat at the table, Nely tapes weekly episodes in English and in Spanish.  Never miss an episode and subscribe to Money Maker here: https://link.chtbl.com/_9U0OQh1?sid=MM

    ClassPass Founder Payal Kadakia on Finding Your Billion Dollar Idea

    ClassPass Founder Payal Kadakia on Finding Your Billion Dollar Idea
    Originally aired 5.4.22 Payal Kadakia, founder of the health app ClassPass, is brilliant— and a perfect example of a founder who keeps it real. Payal doesn’t hide the fact that it took some work to evolve ClassPass into the huge success it is today. In fact, as she tells Nicole, that’s something to be proud of. Nicole gets this lesson and more from Payal in today’s episode.  Want to start investing, but don't know where to begin? Go to moneyassistant.com and meet Magnifi, your AI money assistant, designed to help you make a plan for your financial goals. Want one-on-one money coaching from Nicole? Book a meeting with her here: intro.co/moneynewsnetwork

    Brian Murray (HarperCollins) - A Story of Change and Opportunity

    Brian Murray (HarperCollins) - A Story of Change and Opportunity
    HarperCollins President and CEO Brian Murray discusses the shifting economics of publishing and how his company, which launches 12 new products per day, is working to succeed in this disruptive period. In conversation with STVP Executive Director Dr. Tina Seelig, Murray also talks about issues of digital rights management, his company's willingness to explore new business models, and how HarperCollins manages relationships with other major players in the space.