Logo
    Search

    Vaccinating children, lockdowns, and ebikes

    enFebruary 23, 2022

    Podcast Summary

    • UK recommends COVID-19 vaccines for children aged 5-11The JCVI recommends COVID-19 vaccines for UK children aged 5-11 due to potential health benefits, indirect education effects, and future protection against waves and variants.

      The JCVI, after careful consideration, has recommended that children aged 5 to 11 in the UK receive COVID-19 vaccinations based on the potential health benefits, indirect effects on education, and wider opportunity costs. For children with underlying health issues, the vaccines can prevent a significant number of ICU admissions. For well children, the benefits are much less clear, but the potential for future protection against waves and variants, along with parental demand, were deciding factors. Meanwhile, PlushCare offers online access to board certified physicians who can prescribe weight loss medications for those who qualify, making it easier to start a weight loss journey. Olive and June's at-home manicure system provides salon-quality results for just $2 a manicure, making it a game changer for those seeking convenient and affordable nail care. Finally, a recent study suggests that lockdowns have had minimal impact on reducing global COVID deaths, and Elon Musk has raised concerns about the impact of ebikes on the environment.

    • Benefits of vaccinating children against COVID-19 not clear-cutVaccinating one million children could prevent 0.5-3 ICU admissions during a pandemic wave, but educational disruption and isolation rules outweigh potential benefits, making cost-effectiveness uncertain.

      The benefits of vaccinating children between the ages of 5 and 11 against COVID-19 are not clear-cut. While the estimate is that vaccinating one million children could prevent 3 ICU admissions during a severe wave of the virus, the number drops to 0.5 ICU admissions during a less severe wave. However, there are other potential negative outcomes from getting COVID, such as missed school days or transmission to more at-risk individuals. The educational benefits of vaccination are also small, and the isolation rules are causing more educational disruption than vaccination. The cost-effectiveness argument would not support vaccinating children, but this is a one-off pandemic response. The UK has been reluctant to introduce vaccines for children due to the finely balanced benefits and the availability of safety data from other countries. A study from Johns Hopkins University found that mandatory lockdowns have only reduced COVID-19 mortality by 0.2%, which is a small number considering the significant costs of lockdowns. The study has not received much publicity despite challenging lockdown policies.

    • Study on lockdown impact on COVID mortality controversialA recent study suggests lockdowns in US and Europe reduced COVID mortality by only 0.2%, but its methodology and selection criteria are controversial and more research is needed.

      A recent study claiming mandatory lockdowns in the US and Europe only reduced COVID mortality by 0.2% is controversial due to its methodology. The study was conducted by three economists from Johns Hopkins University, but it wasn't from the School of Public Health. Instead, it focused on statistics of lockdowns. The study used a meta-analysis to combine results from various studies, but its selection criteria excluded most epidemiology department papers. Epidemiologists typically use modeling to explain patterns and generate counterfactuals, while this study focused on comparing populations with varying intervention levels. However, the results were heavily influenced by one research paper from the University of Pretoria, and the Pretoria study reached a different conclusion on lockdowns. Critics argue that the study's methodology and selection criteria were biased, and more research is needed to make definitive conclusions about the impact of lockdowns on COVID mortality.

    • The Effectiveness of Lockdowns and Population Growth DebatedSome studies suggest lockdowns reduce mortality, but their long-term impact is uncertain. Elon Musk worries about population collapse and its implications for Earth and Mars.

      The effectiveness of lockdowns and other mandatory policies during the pandemic is still a subject of ongoing debate among researchers. The interpretation of data and the definition of lockdowns have been sources of controversy. Some studies suggest a strong correlation between lockdowns and a reduction in mortality, as any measure that reduces contact patterns can help limit virus transmission. However, others argue that lockdowns might only postpone the spread of the virus and may not make a significant difference in the long run. Additionally, there is a concern about the accuracy of some studies that focused on mortality as the primary metric, as the time lag between interventions and their effects can lead to misinterpretations. The long-term impact of lockdowns and their role in future pandemics remain uncertain, and further research is needed to better understand their effectiveness. Another topic of discussion was Elon Musk's opinion on population growth, as he expressed concerns about population collapse and the need for sufficient numbers of people for Earth and potential colonies like Mars.

    • Elon Musk's Simple Approach to Predicting Population GrowthMusk's method of predicting population growth by multiplying births by life expectancy is criticized for assuming stability and constant rates, while the UN's more complex methods are widely respected for their accuracy in predicting population trends.

      While the UN and many experts use complex methods to predict population growth, Elon Musk proposes a simpler approach. Musk suggests calculating future populations by multiplying the number of births in a given year by life expectancy. However, this approach has been criticized for assuming a stable population and constant fertility and mortality rates, which are not accurate. Population growth is actually a result of both declining fertility and a large number of births due to the large population in reproductive age, particularly in lower middle income countries. The UN's more complex methods, while criticized for their limitations, are still widely respected for their accuracy in predicting population trends.

    • Assessing fertility rates through cohort analysisExamining fertility rates through the lens of cohort analysis provides a more accurate and consistent assessment of reproductive trends, revealing smoother trends and less steep declines than the commonly used period total fertility rate measure.

      The way we measure fertility rates may not provide the whole picture. While it's concerning that many women are delaying having children, it doesn't necessarily mean they won't have them at all. To get a more accurate assessment, experts suggest looking at the entire reproductive life of a specific cohort, rather than just the number of children born in a given period. This approach, known as cohort fertility rate, shows smoother trends and less steep declines in fertility rates than the commonly used period total fertility rate measure. This is due to the fact that the period fertility rate is susceptible to timing issues, as it only provides a snapshot of fertility at a particular point in time.

    • Electric bikes vs Food's Carbon FootprintElectric bikes emit 5g CO2/mile, while food's carbon footprint varies greatly, with a banana from overseas having up to 40g and a cheeseburger contributing more.

      While electric bikes are more energy-efficient than one might think, the food we consume also has a significant carbon footprint. For instance, an apple from your garden likely has no emissions, but a banana shipped overseas might have used up to 40 grams of CO2. A cheeseburger from methane-belching cows contributes even more. An electric bike, on the other hand, uses only about 5 grams of CO2 to travel a mile when fully powered by the motor. However, it's important to note that electric bikes still require some pedaling, and one estimate suggests you only burn 20% fewer calories on an electric bike compared to a regular one. Additionally, there are assumptions in the calculation, such as the carbon emissions from the UK electric grid and the battery's lifespan. Ultimately, both food and transportation choices have an impact on the environment, and being aware of where and how we get our energy is crucial for addressing climate change. It's also essential to remember that staying active and healthy should not be underrated.

    • Exploring the Power of Dance and Extraordinary Health CareDance connects and entertains us, while extraordinary health care plans make managing out-of-pocket costs easier and 1800flowers.com adds heart to gift-giving

      Dance has the power to connect and entertain, as explored in a new series on BBC Radio 4 and BBC Sounds called "Dancing Legends." Meanwhile, when it comes to health care, being a little extra can be beneficial, and UnitedHealthcare's Health ProtectorGuard fixed indemnity insurance plans make it easier to manage out-of-pocket costs without usual requirements and restrictions. Lastly, 1800flowers.com is more than just a gift-giving destination; they put their hearts into every product and service to help celebrate life's special occasions with loved ones.

    Recent Episodes from More or Less: Behind the Stats

    How a tick box doubled the US maternal mortality rates.

    How a tick box doubled the US maternal mortality rates.

    he US has been portrayed as in the grip of a maternal mortality crisis. In contrast to most other developed nations, the rate of maternal deaths in the US has been going up since the early 2000s.

    But why? With the help of Saloni Dattani, a researcher at Our World in Data, Tim Harford explores how a gradual change in the way the data was gathered lies at the heart of the problem.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Producer: Debbie Richford Production Co-ordinator: Brenda Brown Series Producer: Tom Colls Sound Mix: Emma Harth Editor: Richard Vadon

    Election claims and erection claims

    Election claims and erection claims

    Are Labour right about the Liz Truss effect on mortgages? Are the Conservatives right about pensioners? Are Plaid Cymru right about spending? Are the Lib Dems right about care funding? Is Count Binface right about croissants?

    Why are MRP polls coming up with such different numbers?

    Do erections require a litre of blood?

    Tim Harford investigates the numbers in the news.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Kate Lamble Producers: Simon Tulett, Nathan Gower, Beth Ashmead Latham and Debbie Richford Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Rod Farquhar Editor: Richard Vadon

    Do ‘pig butchering’ cyber scams make as much as half Cambodia’s GDP?

    Do ‘pig butchering’ cyber scams make as much as half Cambodia’s GDP?

    So-called “pig butchering” scams take billions of dollars from people around the globe. But do the cyber scams run from compounds in Cambodia really take an amount of money equivalent to half that country’s GDP? We investigate how the scale of these criminal operations has been calculated.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Andrew Garratt Editor: Richard Vadon

    Worse mortgages, better readers, and potholes on the moon

    Worse mortgages, better readers, and potholes on the moon

    Will Conservative policies raise mortgages by £4800, as Labour claim? Are primary school kids in England the best readers in the (western) world, as the Conservatives claim? Are there more potholes in the UK than craters on the moon?

    Tim Harford investigates some of the numbers in the news.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Kate Lamble Producers: Nathan Gower, Simon Tullet Beth Ashmead-Latham and Debbie Richford Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: James Beard Editor: Richard Vadon

    Shakespeare’s maths

    Shakespeare’s maths

    AWilliam Shakespeare might well rank as the most influential writer in the English language. But it seems he also had a knack for numbers.

    Rob Eastaway, author of Much Ado about Numbers, tells Tim Harford about the simple maths that brings Shakespeare’s work to life.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Readings: Stella Harford and Jordan Dunbar Producer: Beth Ashmead-Latham Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: James Beard Editor: Richard Vadon

    Leaflets, taxes, oil workers and classrooms

    Leaflets, taxes, oil workers and classrooms

    What’s going on with the dodgy bar charts that political parties put on constituency campaign leaflets?

    What’s the truth about tax promises?

    Are 100,000 oil workers going to lose their jobs in Scotland?

    Will class sizes increase in state schools if private schools increase their fees?

    Tim Harford investigates some of the numbers in the news.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporter: Kate Lamble Producers: Nathan Gower, Beth Ashmead-Latham, Debbie Richford Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Neil Churchill Editor: Richard Vadon

    Why medical error is not the third leading cause of death in the US

    Why medical error is not the third leading cause of death in the US

    The claim that medical error is the third leading cause of death in the US has been zooming around the internet for years.

    This would mean that only heart disease and cancer killed more people than the very people trying to treat these diseases.

    But there are good reasons to be suspicious about the claim.

    Professor Mary Dixon-Woods, director of The Healthcare Improvement Studies Institute, or THIS Institute, at Cambridge University, explains what’s going on.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Sound mix: Nigel Appleton Editor: Richard Vadon

    Debate, Reform, tax evasion and ants

    Debate, Reform, tax evasion and ants

    Were there any suspicious claims in the election debate between Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer?

    Do the claims in Reform UK’s policy documents on excess deaths and climate change make sense?

    Can the Conservatives and Labour raise £6bn a year by cracking down on tax avoidance and evasion?

    And do all the humans on earth weigh more than all of the ants?

    Presenter: Tim Harford Reporters: Kate Lamble and Nathan Gower Producer: Beth Ashmead-Latham Series producer: Tom Colls Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Editor: Richard Vadon

    Data for India

    Data for India

    India’s election has been running since 19 April. With results imminent on 4th June, More or Less talks with Chennai based data communicator Rukmini S. She founded Data for India, a new website designed to make socioeconomic data on India easier to find and understand. She talks us through the changing trends to help give a better picture of the type of country the winning party will govern.

    Producers: Bethan Ashmead and Nathan Gower Sound Engineer: Nigel Appleton Production Coordinator: Brenda Brown Editor: Richard Vadon

    UK growth, prisons and Swiftonomics

    UK growth, prisons and Swiftonomics

    Prime Minister Rishi Sunak has said that the UK economy is growing faster than Germany, France and the US, while Labour says the typical household in the UK is worse off by £5,883 since 2019. Are these claims fair? We give some needed context.

    Net migration has fallen - we talk to someone who predicted it would - Dr Madeleine Sumption, director of the Migration Observatory at the University of Oxford.

    Is Taylor Swift about to add £1 bn to the British economy as some media outlets have claimed? The answer is ‘No’.

    Why are our prisons full? We ask Cassia Rowland from the Institute for Government.

    Presenter: Tim Harford Producers: Charlotte McDonald, Nathan Gower, Bethan Ashmead Latham and Ellie House Series producer: Tom Colls Sound mix: Neil Churchill Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Editor: Richard Vadon

    Related Episodes

    Danish Mask Study, Lockdown Dogma Crashes - A Neighbor's Choice

    Danish Mask Study, Lockdown Dogma Crashes - A Neighbor's Choice

    David Gornoski starts the show with a deconstruction of the corporate media's infatuation with Obama. David moves on to comment on a recent Danish study that says, "face masks provide the wearer with only limited protection against COVID-19 infection." What does this mean for the COVID narrative being pushed by the media? David also comments on Klaus Schwab's remarks in his book on the "Great Reset." Listen to the full episode for a rundown on the latest news surrounding the groupthink media, the political establishment's struggle to control the masses, and more.

    Visit A Neighbor's Choice at aneighborschoice.com

    Kanye Fights Back, Dan McCarthy on Biden vs Trump 2020 - A Neighbor's Choice

    Kanye Fights Back, Dan McCarthy on Biden vs Trump 2020 - A Neighbor's Choice

    "In a society where the person is not considered sacred, the person is expendable if enough people say it is." David Gornoski starts the episode by reflecting on Kanye West's tweet on abortion and the four Ds. Joining David is Daniel McCarthy, editor of Modern Age, to comment on Kanye's remarks as well as the upcoming presidential election. Should the big tech censoring issue be handled at the federal level? What is the future of conservatism in America? Listen to the full episode to find out and more.

    Email A Neighbor's Choice with a guest suggestion, story tip or question at hello@aneighborschoice.com
    Find David Gornoski on YouTube
    Visit the A Neighbor's Choice website at aneighborschoice.com

    2022.06.16 Bookworm Video Podcast

    2022.06.16 Bookworm Video Podcast

    I address hope about politics and climate, our reversion to paganism, lockdowns and what they did, the madness of the transgender crowd, and the Uvalde shooting, with my usual side notes into things I find interesting. Links below

    Historic hope: 18th to 19th century England:
    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/4b/The_Rake%27s_Progress_8.jpg
    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/7d/Marriage_A-la-Mode_4%2C_The_Toilette_-_William_Hogarth.jpg
    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/15/GinLane.jpg
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Harlot%27s_Progress#/media/File:Hogarth-Harlot-1.png
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Link-boy#/media/File:Cupid_as_Link_Boy_by_Joshua_Reynolds.jpg
    https://obsessiveskier.blogspot.com/2008/12/votes-for-sale-bribery-and-corruption.html

    Handling emails saying that we’re all going to die from vaccines.
    https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/vaccines/expect/after.html
    https://www.informedchoiceaustralia.com/post/a-staggering-number-of-athletes-collapsed-this-past-year
    https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/vaccines/safety/myocarditis.html

    More evidence, if any is needed, that we’re reverting to pagan times:
    https://www.bookwormroom.com/2021/01/31/the-west-is-reverting-to-paganism/
    https://www.livescience.com/roman-penis-pendant-found-uk
    https://www.livescience.com/roman-penis-graffiti-stone-uk
    https://pagesix.com/2022/06/13/christina-aguilera-wears-strap-on-during-la-pride-performance/

    Yellowstone changes mountain’s name and Mother Nature attacks.
    https://nypost.com/2022/06/11/yellowstones-mount-doane-renamed-to-first-peoples-mountain-for-being-offensive/
    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10913125/Yellowstone-closes-entrances-unprecedented-flooding.html
    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10919573/Yellowstone-closed-indefinitely-thousand-year-flooding.html

    Earth’s magnetic polarity not reversing
    https://www.upi.com/Science_News/2022/06/08/earth-magnetic-polarity-not-reversing-PNAS/7321654702819/

    For Democrats, lockdowns were anything but useless.
    https://instapundit.com/525372/
    https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/516521-democrats-more-likely-to-mail-in-ballots-early-than-republicans-poll/

    Glenn Greenwald and Bradley Manning
    https://nypost.com/2022/06/13/chelsea-manning-details-rift-with-dangerous-glenn-greenwald/

    “It” people
    https://twitter.com/FlorioGina/status/1536752976152432640

    Uvalde:
    https://www.thenewneo.com/2022/06/11/school-police-chief-arredondo-speaks/
    https://piegg.com/blog/2022/05/28/uvalde-school-districts-police-chief-pedro-arredondo-must-resign-after-robb-elementary-massacre-the-daily-beast/

    Plaque of Corruption with Dr. Judy Mikovits

    Plaque of Corruption with Dr. Judy Mikovits
    On May 4th, 2020, part 1 of a documentary series called Plandemic (which featured an interview with whistleblower Dr Judy Mikovits) was released. Analysis by multiple independent groups have estimated that Part 1 has received “over one billion views,” making it the most viewed and banned documentary of all time. Dr. Judy Mikovits is a modern-day Rosalind Franklin, a brilliant researcher shaking up the old boys’ club of science with her ground-breaking discoveries. And like many women who have trespassed into the world of men, she uncovered decades old secrets that many would prefer to stay buried. JUDY A. MIKOVITS, PHD Dr. Judy A. Mikovits earned her BA in chemistry with a specialization in biology from the University of Virginia in 1980 and her PhD in biochemistry and molecular biology from George Washington University in 1992. In her 35-year quest to understand and treat chronic diseases, she has co-authored seminal papers culminating at least a decade of research in each of four fields: immunology, natural products chemistry, epigenetics, and HIV/AIDs drug development. In 2006, she became attracted to the plight of families with neuroimmune diseases including ME/CFS and autism. Dr. Mikovits has been primarily responsible for demonstrating the relationship between environmentally acquired immune dysfunction, chronic inflammation, and these diseases. Dr. Mikovits has published more than 50 peer-reviewed articles, many in the world’s top medical journals and she has been profiled in Discover magazine as well as the Wall Street Journal and The New York Times. Her pioneering work during her 20-year career at the National Cancer Institute includes the discovery of the modulation of DNA methylation machinery by human retro viral infection and the development of the concept of inflammatory cytokines and chemokine signatures of infection and disease, which was first published in 1999, when she directed the Laboratory of Antiviral Drug Mechanisms in developing therapeutics and diagnostics for HIV/AIDS and AIDS associated malignancies. These are all therapies that are still the standard of care twenty-five years later and credited with saving millions of deaths from HIV/AIDS. Website Link:

    The Science: Ivor Cummins Demolishes Lockdowns, Agenda 2030 Policies

    The Science: Ivor Cummins Demolishes Lockdowns, Agenda 2030 Policies

    In this episode of The Science, David Gornoski sits down with Ivor Cummins for a conversation on health, nutrition, and authoritarian lockdowns. Is there any scientific basis for the worldwide lockdowns? What is Agenda 2030? Why is meat consumption being targeted by the elites? Are we headed towards a brighter future, free from tyranny and more innovative than ever before? Listen to the full episode to find out and more.

    Follow Ivor Cummins on Twitter.
    Check out the website of Public Health News here.
    Check out the website of A Neighbor's Choice here.