Logo

    What Everyone Gets Wrong About Mental Health (ft. Lori Gottlieb)

    en-usFebruary 14, 2024
    What is required for successful therapy besides understanding behaviors?
    How does vulnerability impact effective communication and boundaries?
    What does the baby elephant story illustrate about limitations?
    What distinguishes wise compassion from idiot compassion?
    How can therapy help us respond to difficult people?

    Podcast Summary

    • Applying therapy insights in daily lifeEffective therapy requires action outside the room, implementing new insights, and taking responsibility for personal growth.

      Effective therapy goes beyond the therapy room. Merely understanding the reasons behind our behaviors isn't enough; we must actively apply those insights in our daily lives. This means changing our dance steps, or actions, and observing how others respond. Successful therapy requires a readiness to change ourselves rather than just seeking validation for our perspectives. The implementation of new insights is crucial, and it's essential to recognize that personal growth involves taking responsibility for our actions and making necessary adjustments.

    • Understanding and practicing wise compassionTherapy helps us recognize our agency, react differently to difficult people, and utilize our freedom to change and grow, rather than being limited by past experiences.

      Therapy is about practicing wise compassion towards oneself, recognizing one's agency, and bridging the gap between perceived problems and their underlying causes. Idiot compassion, which we use with friends, is different from the wise compassion therapists provide. While there are indeed difficult people in life, our reactions to them are within our control. Therapy helps us understand this and encourages us to react differently. It's not just about the past, but also about being present and making different choices. The metaphor of a prisoner shaking the bars, even when the bars are open, illustrates how we sometimes fail to recognize and utilize our freedom. Similarly, the baby elephant story shows how our past experiences can limit us, even when we have the power to break free. Overall, therapy is about recognizing our power to change and grow.

    • Recognizing Faulty NarrativesUnderstanding and challenging limiting beliefs can reveal the true self in therapy, while effective communication and active listening help determine the right approach when offering advice.

      Our past experiences and the stories we tell ourselves about them can limit us and shape our identities in ways we may not even realize. It's important to recognize that these narratives may not be true and can be a form of avoidance. In therapy, the process of discovery involves uncovering and discarding these faulty narratives to reveal the true self. Additionally, when receiving advice, it's essential to understand what the other person truly needs in that moment. Sometimes, it may just be a desire to be heard and understood, and in such cases, offering advice may not be helpful. Effective communication and active listening can help determine the right approach to providing assistance.

    • Planting seeds of perspectiveEffective communication and empathetic listening can help plant seeds of perspective that may take time to grow. Encourage self-reflection and understanding in therapy sessions and relationships, rather than trying to change or fix others.

      Effective communication and empathetic listening are key to planting seeds of perspective that may take time to grow. Early in one's career, the urge may be to forcefully share opinions and argue, but over time, it's more beneficial to drop seeds of perspective and let the other person decide whether to take them or leave them. This concept can be applied to therapy sessions, where defense mechanisms are used to protect one's sense of self, but can actually hinder growth. Therapists must approach these defenses gently, encouraging self-reflection and understanding, creating a safe space for the individual to try on new ways of being. In relationships, attempting to change or fix others is often unsuccessful, and instead, focusing on communication and understanding can lead to growth for both parties.

    • Focus on personal growth in relationshipsIn relationships, focusing on personal growth and self-compassion is more effective and healthier than trying to change others. The process of change involves several stages and self-compassion is crucial in maintaining progress.

      Focusing on personal growth and change within oneself is a more effective and healthier approach than trying to change or fix others. This concept applies to various aspects of life, including relationships. When entering couples therapy, the therapist encourages each person to set a personal goal for self-improvement, rather than focusing on the other person's actions. People often struggle to change others because it's controlling and difficult to change oneself. The process of change involves several stages, including pre-contemplation, contemplation, preparation, action, and maintenance. Maintenance is a crucial yet often overlooked stage, which involves self-compassion and reflection when falling back into old habits. By focusing on personal growth and self-compassion, individuals can effectively navigate the challenges of change and improve their relationships.

    • Unexpected consequences of making significant life changesMaking major life changes can lead to unforeseen impacts on friendships, hobbies, work, and finances. Prepare for these shifts and seek help when needed.

      Making significant changes in your life can have unexpected and far-reaching effects. The speaker shares his experience of quitting drinking, which led him to reevaluate various aspects of his life, including friendships, hobbies, and work. He emphasizes that these ripple effects can be jarring and challenging to navigate, especially when those around you may not want you to change. The speaker also introduces Rocket Money, a personal finance app that helps users manage and cancel unwanted subscriptions, saving an average of $720 per year. He believes in the power of tracking and maintaining changes, and encourages listeners to check out Rocketmoney.com/idgaf for assistance. Overall, the conversation highlights the importance of being prepared for the unexpected consequences of change and seeking support when needed.

    • Lifestyle changes impact relationshipsEffective communication and finding balance in new shared activities are crucial when making significant lifestyle changes to avoid straining relationships. Small, consistent changes are more sustainable than drastic transformations, and don't forget to enjoy life along the way.

      Making significant lifestyle changes can impact relationships and bring about the need for new shared activities. It's essential to communicate openly and find balance in these changes, avoiding extremes. Small, consistent changes over a long period are more sustainable than drastic transformations. Lastly, it's crucial not to underestimate joy and pleasure in life while making these changes. People deal with similar issues regardless of age, gender, or location, and it's important to remember that others may be experiencing the same challenges.

    • Creating safe spaces for men to open upWomen can play a crucial role in creating safe spaces for men to express emotions, recognizing that vulnerability is uncomfortable for both parties, and understanding that everyone wants love, connection, and validation.

      Men face significant stigma when it comes to expressing their emotions, but the experiences they go through are often universal. Women, in particular, can play a crucial role in creating safe spaces for men to open up. However, it's essential to understand that vulnerability can be uncomfortable for both parties. Many people, regardless of gender, seek validation and reassurance when dealing with emotions, and it's crucial to recognize that these feelings are normal and valid. The speaker's experience of receiving thousands of emails from people all over the world, dealing with various life problems, shows that there are common themes in human experiences. Ultimately, everyone wants to love and be loved, and the desire for understanding and connection is a fundamental human need.

    • The paradox of mental health discussions on social mediaDespite an abundance of resources, mental health is deteriorating. Oversimplifying complex issues on social media may lead to misunderstandings and a lack of relationship repair. Approach mental health discussions with nuance and commitment to repairing relationships.

      While there is an abundance of resources and conversations surrounding mental health, the statistics suggest that mental health is deteriorating rather than improving. This paradox raises concerns about the potential dangers of oversimplifying complex issues, such as trauma or personality disorders, on social media. The prevalence of these discussions may lead to a misunderstanding of what constitutes these conditions and a lack of effort to repair relationships when faced with conflict. Instead, it's crucial to approach mental health discussions with a nuanced understanding and a commitment to repairing relationships when possible. The prevalence inflation hypothesis suggests that the more mental health issues are discussed, the more concept creep occurs, leading to an over-diagnosis of these issues. It's essential to maintain a balanced perspective and not trivialize the significance of mental health challenges.

    • Performative vs True VulnerabilityTrue vulnerability involves sharing deep emotions with trusted individuals in real life, while performative vulnerability is sharing personal information online for validation.

      While mental health discussions have become more common and validated in society, it's important to distinguish between performative vulnerability and true vulnerability. Performative vulnerability involves sharing personal information on social media for validation, while true vulnerability is the act of revealing one's deepest emotions and insecurities to someone trusted in real life, where the stakes are high. The speaker emphasizes the importance of choosing the right audience for vulnerability and addressing issues early on in relationships, before the cement dries. The speaker also shares his experience of the rise of mental health discussions and how it led to people seeking validation for their vulnerability online. It's crucial to remember that true vulnerability requires trust and intentionality, and it's not about seeking validation from strangers on social media.

    • Expressing authenticity, acknowledging rejection, and setting consistent boundariesEffective communication and healthy relationships require vulnerability, consistency, and understanding. Focus on authenticity, ask for what you want, and be open to compromise while acknowledging rejection and maintaining consistent boundaries.

      Effective communication and setting boundaries require vulnerability, consistency, and understanding. Vulnerability means expressing yourself authentically, acknowledging the possibility of rejection, and avoiding manipulation. Consistency is essential in enforcing boundaries, as inconsistency may send mixed messages and undermine their effectiveness. Understanding the importance of connection and recognizing that every person doesn't need to fulfill every role in our lives is crucial. Instead, focus on the benefits each relationship brings and be open to compromise and communication. In romantic relationships, remember that no one can meet every need, and it's essential to ask for what you want while being attentive to your partner's feelings as well. Ultimately, maintaining healthy relationships involves a balance of vulnerability, consistency, and understanding.

    • Balancing Flexibility and Boundaries in RelationshipsFind balance in relationships by setting boundaries and being flexible. A good therapist helps set goals, work towards progress, and move on when goals are met.

      Flexibility is crucial in relationships, but it's important to find a balance between being rigid and having boundaries. Rigidity can hinder intimacy, while being too boundariless can lead to unhealthy relationships. The friction and imperfections in relationships can bring us closer together, and it's essential to be open to working through these challenges with a therapist. A good therapist should help you set specific goals and work towards leaving therapy once those goals are met. Continuously staying in therapy without making progress may indicate that something is not working. Ultimately, therapy is a tool for growth and self-improvement, and the goal is to use it to make positive changes in your life before moving on.

    • The importance of authenticity in therapyAuthenticity in therapy builds strong relationships and resonates with patients, often more than credentials or theoretical orientation.

      Authenticity and building a strong therapeutic relationship are crucial in the success of therapy. Patients value the genuine experience of connecting with their therapist, which often matters more than their credentials or theoretical orientation. The therapist in the discussion shared how her book, "Maybe You Should Talk to Someone," resonated with readers due to its raw and authentic portrayal of human experiences. The therapist continues to write, podcast, and is developing a TV series based on her book. While she cannot reveal details about her upcoming book yet, she is excited about it and emphasizes the importance of staying true to oneself in both personal and professional endeavors.

    • New series about therapists with authentic portrayalJason Kadamus is creating a new series about therapists, focusing on their professionalism and boss role, aiming for an authentic representation without stereotypes.

      Jason Kadamus, known for his work on "Friday Night Lights" and "Parenthood," is creating a new series about therapists, aiming for a more authentic and less stereotypical portrayal. Instead of the typical couch setup, the focus will be on the therapist as a professional and a boss figure. Kadamus and Laurie Gottlieb had a conversation about the project during the podcast episode, with the hope of avoiding clichéd depictions. Listeners are encouraged to follow the show, leave a review, and visit markmanson.net/audit for a free 2024 life audit to help improve their year. The new series is an exciting development in the representation of therapists on screen.

    Recent Episodes from The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck Podcast

    Self-Help Junkies, Stupid Experts, and the Worst Life Advice I've Ever Heard

    Self-Help Junkies, Stupid Experts, and the Worst Life Advice I've Ever Heard

    Are you addicted to self-improvement? Are experts really any better than the rest of us at knowing how to make positive changes in our lives? What are some common pieces of life advice that just don't seem to work?

    Drew and I tackle all of these questions today in our brand new, updated format for the pod. Find out why self-help can turn into pseudo-religion (and why we should bring back exorcisms), whether or not a huge mega-study by a bunch of fancy experts can tell us anything about behavioral change, and some common self-improvement tropes that just don't do it for us.

    Here's the study we discuss: Megastudies improve the impact of applied behavioural science

    Let us know what you think of the new show format in the comments below.

    Use code MARK to get 15% off your order of health tech gear at https://BonCharge.com

    Get one month of Shopify for just $1 at https://shopify.com/idgaf

    Get 10% off health services at https://marekhealth.com/idgaf

    And sign up for Your Next Breakthrough, my weekly newsletter that will help you be a slightly less awful person: https://markmanson.net/breakthrough

    Got a question for us? Leave it in the comments below or send it to podcast@markmanson.net

    Theme song is "Icarus Lives" by Periphery.

    Resistance, Self-Sabotage, and What It Really Takes to Accomplish Dreams (ft. Steven Pressfield)

    Resistance, Self-Sabotage, and What It Really Takes to Accomplish Dreams (ft. Steven Pressfield)

    Steven Pressfield was 52 years old when he published his first hit novel, The Legend of Bagger Vance. Prior to that, he wrote tirelessly for decades in obscurity, supporting himself with odd jobs along the way.


    After writing several more novels and movie scripts, he distilled all of his wisdom into The War of Art, his now-famous treatise on the grinding process of creativity.


    Now in his 80s, Steven looks back on his work and life with a clear-eyed view of what it truly means to make it as a creative professional. In this episode, he explains why he persisted writing for decades with little to show for it, how he compensated for his own lack of talent, why creating great art is actually a grueling war fought within the artist’s own mind, and much, much more.


    Enjoy.


    Steven’s new book, The Daily Pressfield


    All of Steven Pressfield's Books


    Get up to 43% off your order of MUD/WTR at mudwtr.com/idgaf


    Use code IDGAF to get 10% Marek Health services at marekhealth.com/idgaf


    Get 10% off your first month of therapy at betterhelp.com/idgaf


    Sign up for my newsletter, Your Next Breakthrough. It will help make you a less awful person: markmanson.net/breakthrough

    5 Ways to Be Self-Disciplined Without Making Yourself Miserable

    5 Ways to Be Self-Disciplined Without Making Yourself Miserable

    We often think self-discipline requires massive action and a lot of pain and sacrifice—but the reality is a lot more boring. Today, we tackle some common misconceptions about self-discipline, arguing that real change comes from setting up your environment for success, not grinding through endless struggle.


    We explore the hidden dangers of romanticizing pain and why true self-discipline is more about boring consistency than epic feats of endurance. Hopefully, this episode challenges you to rethink how you approach your goals and habits. If you're ready to stop punishing yourself and start seeing real, lasting change, you won’t want to miss this.


    Use code IDGAF to Get 20% off your one-time purchase of supplements at https://livemomentous.com


    Get your first bag of Trade coffee for free when you sign up for a subscription at https://tradecoffee.com/idgaf


    Use code IDGAF to get 15% off your first purchase of skincare products at https://OneSkin.co


    Sign up for my newsletter, Your Next Breakthrough. It will help you be a less awful person: https://markmanson.net/breakthrough

    Bonus Q&A: Facing Regrets, Hustle Culture, Living with ADHD, and More

    Bonus Q&A: Facing Regrets, Hustle Culture, Living with ADHD, and More

    It’s bonus episode time! Today, I’m doing a Q&A with questions you’ve all submitted. We dive into how I’ve changed my mind, bad habits, regrets, dead dreams, advice to young people, meditation, and a whole lot more.

    Submit your questions for future podcasts in the comments or email them to podcast@markmanson.net.

    Sign up for my newsletter, Your Next Breakthrough. It will help you be a less awful person: https://markmanson.net/breakthrough

    How To Be Successful in a World That Wasn’t Built for You (ft. Astronaut Cady Coleman)

    How To Be Successful in a World That Wasn’t Built for You (ft. Astronaut Cady Coleman)

    How do you find your way in a world where even when you do everything right, the odds keep getting stacked against you? My guest today, Cady Coleman, shares how she navigated the male-dominated fields of science, the Air Force, and NASA, breaking down barriers with tenacity and grace.


    From her time on the International Space Station to the release of her first book, Sharing Space, Cady’s story is a powerful reminder of the importance of mission, adaptability, and the unwavering belief in one’s potential, even when the world around you says otherwise.


    Check it out.


    Control body odor ANYWHERE with @shop.mando and get $5 off off your Starter Pack (that’s over 40% off) with promo code IDGAF at shopmando.com! #mandopod


    Start selling online and get your first month of Shopify for just $1 at shopify.com/idgaf


    Cady’s Book, Sharing Space: https://www.amazon.com/Sharing-Space-Astronauts-Mission-Wonder/dp/0593494016


    Sign up for my newsletter, Your Next Breakthrough. It will make you a slightly less awful person: https://markmanson.net/breakthrough

    6 Ways to Stop Giving a F*ck

    6 Ways to Stop Giving a F*ck

    We all wish we gave fewer f*cks in our lives, but wanting to and doing it are two different things. If you've read my book, The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck, then you know that not giving a f*ck doesn't mean you don't care about anything—it means deliberately choosing what you give a f*ck about and ignore the rest.

    In this episode, we dive into the realities of not giving f*ck, the good and the bad. We talk about why there will never be a time when you're completely free from judgement by others. Why being "normal"—whatever that means—is not something to aspire to, nor is wanting to be liked by everyone. How criticism is a part of life you can't escape—but not all criticism is created equal. And a whole lot more.

    Check it out.

    Get 10% off your first month of therapy at Better Help: https://betterhelp.com/idgaf

    Use the promo code IDGAF to get 20% off your first order of supplements at Momentous: https://www.livemomentous.com/

    Sign up for my newsletter, Your Next Breakthrough, to be a slightly less awful person: https://markmanson.net/breakthrough

    It's Never Too Late to Turn Your Life Around (ft. Brandon Novak)

    It's Never Too Late to Turn Your Life Around (ft. Brandon Novak)

    Brandon Novak showed all the signs of becoming a highly successful, rebellious young man. He was a professional skateboarder in his early teens, rubbing elbows with the likes of Bucky Lasek and Tony Hawk. In his late teens and twenties, he was a regular on world-famous TV shows like Viva La Bam and Jackass.

    But drugs and alcohol were always lurking in the shadows for Novak, and he soon fell head-first into the dark trap of his addictions. He endured bouts of homelessness, committed every petty crime you could imagine, and even resorted to sex work to feed his addictions.

    The stats would suggest Brandon Novak shouldn’t be sober right now. He probably shouldn’t even be alive. But not only is he alive with 9 years of sobriety under his belt, he’s found a deep and meaningful purpose in his life, running his own rehab centers and taking care of his elderly mother.

    This is the hilarious and heartening story of how Brandon Novak turned it all around. And trust me, if he can do it, so can anyone else.

    Use promo code IDGAF to get 20% your Cuts clothing order at https://cutsclothing.com

    Use promo code IDGAF to get 15% off your order at OneSkin at https://oneskin.co

    Get 10% off your supplements order at Market Health at https://marekhealth.com/idgaf

    Sign up for my newsletter, Your Next Breakthrough, to be a slightly less awful person: https://markmanson.net/breakthrough

    The Backwards Law: How to Get More by Doing Less

    The Backwards Law: How to Get More by Doing Less

    There are certain areas in life where trying harder only makes things worse. Trying to prove how likable and confident you are only makes you feel more unlikable and less confident. Trying to make someone love you only makes you feel more unlovable.

    The solution to this conundrum is what’s known as “The Backwards Law”.

    Simply put, The Backwards law states that desiring a positive experience is itself a negative experience, while accepting a negative experience is a positive experience.

    In this episode, Drew and I talk about five areas of life where doing less can actually reap massive benefits.

    Enjoy.

    Get your first month of Shopify for only $1 at https://shopify.com/idgaf

    Use the code IDGAF to get 20% off your one-time purchase of supplements at https://LiveMomentous.com

    Sign up for Your Next Breakthrough, a weekly newsletter that will make you a less awful person: https://markmanson.net/breakthrough

    Are Smartphones Really Ruining Our Lives… Or Is It Something Else? (ft. Jonathan Haidt)

    Are Smartphones Really Ruining Our Lives… Or Is It Something Else? (ft. Jonathan Haidt)

    Is everything going to hell in a handcart because of smartphones and social media? In this episode, I sit down with NYU professor and bestselling author Jonathan Haidt to tackle this burning question.

    Dr. Haidt makes a compelling case that our addiction to these devices is wreaking havoc on society, from mental health crises to political turmoil. But is it really all the smartphone’s fault? I'm not so sure it's quite that simple, so I wanted to dive deeper into the nuances.

    We get into the nitty-gritty and I challenge some of Haidt’s claims, exploring questions like, why do these issues seem to hit the English-speaking world the hardest? Is this another moral panic, or is this time really different? We also discuss the differences in how smartphones affect various demographics and cultures, and why understanding these distinctions is crucial. Plus, we explore Jonathan’s practical and highly sensible recommendations for parents, educators, and policymakers.

    Whether you’re a skeptic or a die-hard believer, this episode will make you rethink your relationship with the technology in our pockets.

    Let's do this.

    Start your new morning ritual & get up to 43% off your @MUDWTR by going to ⁠mudwtr.com/IDGAF⁠! #mudwtrpod

    Get 10% off your first month of therapy at BetterHelp.com/IDGAF

    How I Lost 60 Pounds and Started Giving A F*ck About My Health

    How I Lost 60 Pounds and Started Giving A F*ck About My Health

    Over the past 5 years, I’ve completely changed my relationship to my health. Prior to that, I was overweight, pre-diabetic, and having chest pains in my mid-30s. I thought maybe eating a salad once a week and going for a run every now then would take care of it. I was wrong.

    Since then, I’ve lost 60 pounds (~30kg). I now enjoy exercising regularly and I eat healthy and nutritious foods. My daily life is much more physically active and I get way better sleep. I’m happy with my health now—but it took a long time to get here.

    I’m not going to share a bunch of workout routines or complicated diets. What worked for me might not work for you. But I can share what I went through to get here in the hopes that you, too, might change how you think about your health and take it more seriously. Because at the end of the day, your health is definitely something you should give a f*ck about.

    Use the code IDGAF to get 20% off your first one-time purchase of supplements at livemomentous.com

    Related Episodes

    Our Marriage Is Toxic

    Our Marriage Is Toxic
    On this episode, we hear about: -       A husband wondering if his toxic marriage can be healed -       A woman worried about her relationship with alcohol -       A woman struggling with panic attacks at work Let us know what’s going on by leaving a voicemail at 844.693.3291 or visiting johndelony.com/show.  Support Our Sponsors: BetterHelp Hallow Organifi Eight Sleep Apollo Neuro Thorne Add products to your cart create an account at checkout Receive 25% off ALL orders This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at https://www.betterhelp.com/delony and get on your way to being your best self. Resources: Building a Non-Anxious Life Anxiety Test Own Your Past, Change Your Future Questions for Humans Conversation Cards John’s Free Guided Meditation Listen to all The Ramsey Network podcasts anytime, anywhere in our app. Download at: https://apple.co/3eN8jNq These platforms contain content, including information provided by guests, that is intended for informational and entertainment purposes only. The content is not intended to replace or substitute for any professional medical, counseling, therapeutic, financial, legal, or other advice. The Lampo Group, LLC d/b/a Ramsey Solutions as well as its affiliates and subsidiaries (including their respective employees, agents and representatives) make no representations or warranties concerning the content and expressly disclaim any and all liability concerning the content including any treatment or action taken by any person following the information offered or provided within or through this show. If you have specific concerns or a situation in which you require professional advice, you should consult with an appropriately trained and qualified professional expert and specialist. If you are having a health or mental health emergency, please call 9-1-1 immediately. Learn more about your ad choices. https://www.megaphone.fm/adchoices Ramsey Solutions Privacy Policyv

    Food For Thought: Operational Definitions

    Food For Thought: Operational Definitions
    Sometimes we have a conversation with another person about one concept that has two very different meanings for each of us. More often, we don't even realize it. 

    It’s such a simple concept yet one that can completely transform the way we communicate with and understand other people. 

    We would truly appreciate your feedback. Please help us build a better BBXX for you by sending your questions, comments, or criticisms to hello@bbxx.world or by texting +1 (415) 888-4742 :) 

    "I feel so much better not going to therapy. Does this mean I am done with therapy?"

    "I feel so much better not going to therapy. Does this mean I am done with therapy?"

    *This was first recorded as a facebook live*

    Olivia Pelts, owner of Sunshine City Counseling in St. Petersburg, FL, is addressing this question:

    "I am starting to take a break from therapy because I’m frustrated with my therapist. I feel so much better not going to therapy. Does this mean I am done with therapy or that I had a bad therapist?"

    This is a question we often hear at SCC. Check this quick episode for Olivia's thoughts...

    Cheering You On,

    The Team at Sunshine City Counseling

    Want to do individual counseling, couples counseling or child and teen therapy with one of the counselors at Sunshine City Counseling? Head over to the website and schedule your first free session.

    https://www.sunshinecitycounseling.com/new-clients

    We're ready when you are.

    IG: @thesunshinecity

    Email: info@sunshinecitycounseling.com

    Food For Thought: Memory Tissue

    Food For Thought: Memory Tissue
    As hard as we might try to forget or "get over" things, the body still remembers them. Studies show that suppressing emotions can do damage not only to our psychological health but also to our physical health.

    We would truly appreciate your feedback. Please help us build a better BBXX for you by sending your questions, comments, or criticisms to hello@bbxx.world or by texting +1 (415) 888-4742 :)