Logo
    Search

    Will Saletan: The Politics of Atonement

    en-usSeptember 26, 2023

    Podcast Summary

    • Courage and truth-telling: Young vs OldCourage and truth-telling, essential for accountability, were exemplified by Cassidy Hutchinson's testimony against those in power, contrasting with some older men's unwillingness to atone and tell the truth.

      Courage and truth-telling, regardless of age or gender, are essential for holding those in power accountable. The contrasting actions of Cassidy Hutchinson, a young woman, and some older men in the former Trump administration highlight this. Hutchinson's decision to testify truthfully about the events of January 6th, despite the potential backlash, demonstrates the importance of personal integrity and the clarity it brings. The older men, encrusted by their beliefs and rationalizations, failed this test. This situation raises questions about what motivates some individuals to atone and tell the truth, while others refuse. The psychological, theological, and age-related aspects of this issue warrant further exploration.

    • Individuals have the power to make a differenceEven in seemingly hopeless situations, individuals can stand up for what's right and make a difference. The Republican Party can learn from past mistakes and choose to uphold democratic values and principles.

      No matter how deeply entrenched one may be in a situation or belief, there's always a chance to do the right thing. Cassidy Hutchinson's poise and courage in testifying against former President Trump serves as a reminder that individuals have the power to make a difference, even when it seems like the situation is hopeless. The Republican Party's choices in the past do not dictate its future. It's crucial for politicians to take a stand against destructive behaviors and actions, especially when it comes to preserving democracy. The future of the party lies in making clear distinctions between the Reagan and Trump eras, acknowledging the differences in policy, character, and principle. It's never too late to choose the right path, and the opportunity for redemption and growth is always present.

    • The future of conservatism lies with the new generationNew leaders may learn from past mistakes and steer conservatism differently, but the upcoming elections raise questions about putting power in hands of those who have shown disregard for democratic norms.

      The future of conservatism lies in the hands of the new generation, who have the power to learn from past mistakes and steer the movement in a different direction. The testimony of figures like Cassidy Hutchinson, who have spoken out against the actions of some in the party, gives hope that this may happen. However, it's important to remember that she was a part of the Trump White House and faced severe backlash for her statements. The upcoming elections raise important questions about whether we want to put people in power who have shown a willingness to overturn elections and mishandle sensitive national security information. Despite Biden's historically low approval ratings, polls suggest that the upcoming election could be a close race. It's crucial to take polls seriously as warnings, rather than denying their results or dismissing them outright. The challenge is to respond to reality checks in a constructive way, rather than deepening denial bubbles.

    • Addressing pressing issues in politicsAcknowledging and addressing important matters in politics, such as Joe Biden's age, Trump's threats, and corruption, is crucial for society. Stay informed and engaged to maintain the health of our democracy.

      It's crucial for individuals and society as a whole to acknowledge and address pressing issues instead of ignoring them. The discussion touched upon the importance of Joe Biden addressing his age and the threat posed by Donald Trump, as well as the MAGA world's obsession with targeting young women like Taylor Swift. Additionally, the indictment of Robert Menendez, a prominent senator, serves as a reminder of the seriousness of corruption and its potential national security implications. It's essential to remain vigilant and engage in civil debate to ensure the health of our democracy. Don't forget to check out The Bulwark for daily doses of truth and sanity in politics.

    • Senator Robert Menendez's Defiant Response to Bribery AllegationsDespite clear evidence and potential damage to his reputation, Senator Robert Menendez has defiantly explained his acceptance of bribes by citing his family's history and financial practices, rather than showing remorse or asking for forgiveness.

      Robert Menendez, a Democratic senator from New Jersey, has been accused of accepting bribes totaling $480,000 in cash, which he left around his house. Instead of acknowledging his actions or asking for forgiveness, Menendez has defiantly explained his behavior by citing his family's history of suffering under the Cuban government and his practice of keeping cash for emergencies. However, the bills found in his house have only been minted in the last 10 years, and the DNA of the Egyptian bribers is on them. Menendez's actions are particularly egregious given that he is using his family's history and his Latino identity as a victim card, despite being a crook. The prayer book mentions asking forgiveness for accepting bribes, but Menendez has not shown any remorse or honesty. The evidence against him is clear, and his behavior is not only shameless but also insulting to those who have legitimately faced discrimination.

    • Democratic vs. Republican responses to corruption allegationsWhile Trump receives unwavering GOP support, Menendez faces reluctance from Dems to call for his resignation due to Senate dynamics and clubbiness.

      The Democratic response to corruption allegations against their own members, like Senator Bob Menendez, contrasts significantly with the Republican response to similar allegations against their leader, Donald Trump. While Trump receives unwavering support from his party, Menendez faces a reluctance from Democrats to call for his resignation. This reluctance can be attributed to the unique dynamics of the Senate, where the "innocent until proven guilty" defense is used consistently, and the clubby nature of the Senate makes it difficult for senators to turn on each other. However, as more evidence emerges and elections approach, we can expect more Democratic senators to call for Menendez's resignation. Despite his past indiscretions and ongoing allegations, Menendez's shamelessness and arrogance make it unlikely that he will step down voluntarily.

    • Political Drama in D.C.: Menendez, Shutdown, and McCarthy's LeadershipMenendez's behavior raises questions, but ethnicity should not be the focus. The potential government shutdown lacks clear objectives, affecting businesses and families. McCarthy's response to the situation reflects earlier concessions, leading to the current impasse.

      The ongoing political drama in Washington D.C. involves several contentious issues, including potential government shutdown, accusations against Senator Menendez, and Kevin McCarthy's leadership. Regarding Menendez, some argue that his behavior, including hoarding wealth due to fear and playing the ethnicity card, is irrational and compulsive. However, it's crucial for Democrats and Latinos not to jump to conclusions based on ethnicity. As for the potential government shutdown, it's not surprising given the current political climate, and the Chamber of Commerce's Neil Bradley calls it the "Seinfeld shutdown" due to the lack of clear objectives. McCarthy's response to the situation reflects his earlier concessions to extremist Republicans, leading to the current impasse. Ultimately, the consequences of these political actions will impact American businesses and families.

    • Political Stalemate in US House: Chaos and Outrage, Not PolicyThe US House political stalemate is driven by a desire for chaos and outrage, not policy or governing. McCarthy's allegiance to Trump and fear of being replaced hinder his ability to work with Democrats, leading to a fight with no end goal beyond the act of fighting itself.

      The current political stalemate in the US House of Representatives is not about policy or governing, but rather about the desire to create chaos and outrage. Kevin McCarthy, the Speaker of the House, is caught between two groups: those who want to burn down the government and those who want to work with Democrats to pass legislation. McCarthy's allegiance to Donald Trump and fear of being replaced hinders his ability to work with Democrats, leading him to choose to work with the "burners" instead. The fight is no longer about winning or accomplishing anything, but rather about the act of fighting itself. This mentality is not limited to those in the majority and can be seen in those who are not in power as well. The normal political incentives do not apply, and the desire to cause chaos and gin up outrage is the coin of the realm for some politicians.

    • The Republican Party's entertainment wing holds no real powerDespite their antics, the GOP's entertainment wing lacks governing power, while Biden's union support signals commitment to working class agenda

      The Republican Party's entertainment wing, which includes some members like Matt Gaetz, holds no real power or responsibility, making them irrelevant when it comes to governance. This was highlighted during the recent elections, as the outcome had no significant impact on Gates or McCarthy's lack of leverage over the "burners." Meanwhile, President Biden's decision to join the UAW picket line, the first time a sitting U.S. president has done so, is a calculated risk. Politically, it signals Biden's commitment to the working class agenda and his unwillingness to concede it to Trump. However, from a policy standpoint, the White House would have preferred the president to stay away and delegate the task to someone else. The left faces a challenge in connecting with workers outside of unionized environments, as seen in the UAW's hesitance to endorse Biden, despite their criticism of Trump. The erosion of the working class as a central part of the Democratic Coalition is a complex issue, involving cultural and other factors, and requires a nuanced approach from the party.

    • Tension between green agenda and working class agenda in auto industryBiden must help unionize electric car plants and address economic concerns like inflation to win back working class voters.

      There is tension between the green agenda and the working class agenda, specifically in relation to the automobile industry and the shift towards electric vehicles. This tension stems from the potential loss of jobs for UAW members due to the fewer workers required to manufacture electric vehicles and the possibility of these jobs moving to non-union areas. Joe Biden must address this issue by taking substantive action to help unionize the plants producing electric cars. Furthermore, the Democratic Party needs to acknowledge the concerns of the working class and address economic issues, such as inflation, which disproportionately affects them. The larger theme for the Democrats should be promoting shared economic growth. The underlying question is to what extent have working class people left the Democratic party due to both cultural and economic issues. By addressing these economic concerns, the Democrats may be able to win back some of these voters.

    • Democrats focus on economic growth and fair sharing vs. RepublicansDemocrats emphasize economic growth and fairness, while Republicans focus on profits. Trump's violent rhetoric distracts from larger issues, endangering democracy.

      The Democratic Party's focus on economic growth and fair sharing can position them against the Republican Party, especially when it comes to issues like the automakers' profits and workers' wages. However, the escalating rhetoric of political violence and retribution, as displayed by former President Trump, is a concerning trend that requires attention. Trump's calls for harsh penalties and violence against his opponents are dangerous and distract from a larger agenda. The normalization of such rhetoric is a problem for the health of American democracy. Cassidy Hutchinson's testimony serves as a reminder that this issue is bigger than a Trump problem. It's important for individuals and political parties to recognize the potential harm of such rhetoric and work towards de-escalation and unity.

    • The Dangers of Authoritarianism and Republican Support for TrumpRepublican support for Trump is disqualifying and dangerous, emphasizing the importance of speaking out against authoritarianism and holding accountable those who enable it.

      The continued support of an authoritarian figure like Donald Trump by an entire political party, such as the Republicans, is disqualifying and dangerous. This is not just a reason to prevent Trump from becoming president again, but also to prevent the election of Republicans to various offices, including the House, Senate, and governorships. If only there had been clear warnings about the dangers of such alignment. It's crucial for everyone to understand that this behavior is harmful and should not be tolerated. The Bulwark podcast discussion underscores the importance of speaking out against authoritarianism and holding accountable those who support it.

    Recent Episodes from The Bulwark Podcast

    Clint Smith: A Reckoning with History

    Clint Smith: A Reckoning with History
    Author, poet, and native New Orleanian Clint Smith grew up in the city that was the heart of the domestic slave trade, but realized his understanding of the history within himself and his country was inadequate. So he set out to write the type of book he should have had in high school. On this Independence Day, we pulled a special selection from the Tim Miller Bulwark archive. Plus, love for the Crescent City, and dads getting too much credit for pulling their weight.

    show notes


    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJuly 04, 2024

    Jon Lovett: Unprecedented Times

    Jon Lovett: Unprecedented Times
    The quiet coming from the White House sure suggests that the people around the president don't think Joe at his best can overcome Joe at his worst. Jon Lovett joins Tim Miller to discuss all the possible options as the world waits for Biden to say what he's going to do.
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJuly 03, 2024

    Ben Wittes and Steven Shepard: He Is Still a Criminal

    Ben Wittes and Steven Shepard: He Is Still a Criminal
    No matter how much the Supreme Court pretends that the words 'high crimes and misdemeanors' are not explicitly in the Constitution, Donald Trump is still a disqualified law-breaker and is exactly the kind of guy the Founding Fathers warned us about. Character is now the only real check on presidential power. Plus, if push comes to shove, what are the basic rules that govern a change at the top of the ticket? Ben Wittes and Steven Shepard join Tim Miller.

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJuly 02, 2024

    Tom Nichols: Political Malpractice

    Tom Nichols: Political Malpractice
    All Americans who love this country and hate Donald Trump deserve answers about Thursday's abysmal performance—and how we are going to move forward. And do not answer our doubts about Biden and his staff with a MAGA-style blaming-the-press bit. Meanwhile, the Supreme Court recklessly assists Trump yet again, and Bannon goes to the big house. Tom Nichols joins Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Mika Brzezinski on Joe Biden

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJuly 01, 2024

    Sarah Longwell, Jonathan V. Last, and Jonathan Martin: A Disaster

    Sarah Longwell, Jonathan V. Last, and Jonathan Martin: A Disaster
    The Secret Pod makes an emergency appearance to work through last night's terrible performance by Biden and to urge the Democratic Party to do the responsible thing in this moment. And Jonathan Martin discusses the strategy behind Biden's failed gamble and whether sitting Democrats would actually publicly push the president to leave the ticket. Sarah Longwell, JVL, and Martin join Tim Miller for the weekend pod.

    show notes:

    Claire McCaskill on Biden's performance
    David Frum on the debate
    Tim's playlist 

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 28, 2024

    Kate Bedingfield and Marc Caputo: Debate Day

    Kate Bedingfield and Marc Caputo: Debate Day
    Former White House comms director Kate Bedingfield serves up some keen insights into Poppa Joe—he is a night person, he regularly seeks out Jill's opinion, and he is a calming influence. And he's probably not as anxious as Tim Miller is about tonight's debate. Meanwhile, Marc Caputo reports from Magaville on Trump's posturing that he is definitely, absolutely not at all prepping for the debate. Your pre-fight night comfort food to calm the jitters.

    show notes:

    Kevin Williamson piece Tim mentioned

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 27, 2024

    Stuart Stevens: I think Joe Biden Has Been A Great President

    Stuart Stevens: I think Joe Biden Has Been A Great President
    So many of the people who worked around POTUS 44 think no one will ever be as good as Obama, but Stuart Stevens argues that Democrats need to make the case that Joe Biden is a great president. Meanwhile, Dems on Tuesday showed they are the one party holding their crazy people to account. Plus, Vance is too smart to be Trump's VP pick, more Republicans need to follow Kinzinger's example, and Ole Miss, college sports and civil rights. Tim Miller's show today.

    show notes:

    Stuart's latest book, "The Conspiracy to End America"
    Stuart's book, "The Last Season: A Father, a Son, and a Lifetime of College Football"
    Wright Thompson's piece on Ole Miss in 1962
    Stuart's piece on calling Biden a great president 

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 26, 2024

    Symone Sanders-Townsend: Don't Say We Didn't Warn You

    Symone Sanders-Townsend: Don't Say We Didn't Warn You
    Project 2025 sounds mundane, but it would institutionalize Trumpism, eliminate the Department of Education, mass deport 11 million people, and turn the Department of Health and Human Services into the Department of "Life." Plus, more from the mailbag, and Biden finding the sweet spot between Uncle Joe and punching Trump in the face. Symone Sanders-Townsend joins Tim Miller.

    show notes:

    Symone's interview on Project 2025
    MSNBC Live: Democracy 2024 event in September

    Tim's Mount Rushmore of political books:
    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 25, 2024

    Jared Polis and Bill Kristol: Live from Denver

    Jared Polis and Bill Kristol: Live from Denver
    Gov. Jared Polis says Biden should focus on what he'll do for the American people in his campaign, rather than getting caught up in the crazy of Trump. Plus, guns, weed, the value of talking across party lines, and how Colorado is trying to avoid California's housing and growth problems. Tim Miller was live with Polis on Friday. And Bill Kristol joined Monday to discuss Trump's penchant for lying and to preview Tuesday's primaries.

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 24, 2024

    Jane Coaston: He's So Not a Badass

    Jane Coaston: He's So Not a Badass
    Trump is not drawing support from black voters because of his criminality—that's just MAGA's bigotry of low expectations. Meanwhile, he's now promising a green card to every foreign Harvard grad to please tech bro donors. Plus, the attempt to create a race war over Caitlin Clark, the annoying liberals on the coasts are creating MAGA reactionaries, and more from the mailbag. Jane Coaston joins Tim Miller for the weekend pod.

    show notes:

    Reid Hoffman's reply to David Sacks
    Tim interviews Reid Hoffman
    Tim's playlist 

    The Bulwark Podcast
    en-usJune 21, 2024

    Related Episodes

    Susan Glasser: Trump 2024 Is Scarier than Trump 2020

    Susan Glasser: Trump 2024 Is Scarier than Trump 2020

    Trump's rhetoric is more apocalyptic and more confrontational, and the party still can't renounce its addiction to the man. This is Trump without guardrails. Plus, the long shadow the Iraq War has cast on our foreign policy and presidential elections. The New Yorker's Susan Glasser joins Charlie Sykes today.

    show notes

    Recent pieces by Susan:

    The G.O.P. and the Ghosts of Iraq

    2024 Trump Is Even Scarier than 2020 Trump

    Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

    Can We Become Re-sensitized to Crazy Before It’s Too Late? ft. Tara Setmayer

    Can We Become Re-sensitized to Crazy Before It’s Too Late? ft. Tara Setmayer

    This has not been a great week for Fox News or Ron DeSantis. Tara Setmayer joins us to discuss the fallout from the Dominion Voting Systems settlement with Fox News and weighs in on the 2024 presidential election. She expresses deep concern for the way in which the media is contributing to the “desensitization of crazy” and how some channels are already covering 2024 presidential election as if it were a regular election. “It feels like Groundhog Day,” says Setmayer, about the media making the same mistakes as they did in 2016. This is the time for journalists and media to seriously consider the way they approach coverage and content of politics generally and elections specifically. Tara also discusses what the Republican Party should do to rebuild. “People don’t change until they’ve paid enough of a price. Republicans need to get with it. They can’t continue to shrink their voting base.” 

    Tara Setmayer is contributor to ABC News, MSNBC and former GOP Communications Director on Capitol Hill. She’s appeared on ABC‘s The View, ABC’s Good Morning America, and on HBO‘s Real Time with Bill Maher. In January 2020, she joined The Lincoln Project as a senior advisor and hosts the live show “The Breakdown” along side co-founder Rick Wilson, on the organization’s streaming channel, LPTV.

    What Happens When Democracy Threatens to Unravel? ft. Liz Cheney

    What Happens When Democracy Threatens to Unravel? ft. Liz Cheney

    Center for Politics Professor of Practice Liz Cheney sat down with Center for Politics Director Larry J. Sabato and other members of our team this week for a discussion about the challenges facing American politics and democracy. She speaks out for the first time about the new Speaker of House Mike Johnson (R-LA-4) and why he is dangerous. Cheney’s forthcoming book, Oath and Honor: A Memoir and a Warning, is now available for pre-order and will be released on December 5, 2023. Cheney, former chair of the House Republican Conference, joined the Center for Politics as Professor of Practice in March.

    ' It was an attack on democracy; it was terrorism' ft. Officer Daniel Hodges

    ' It was an attack on democracy; it was terrorism' ft. Officer Daniel Hodges

    As we commemorate the third anniversary of the attacks on the U.S. Capitol, we talk with DC Metropolitan Police Officer Daniel Hodges. On January 6, 2021, Ofc. Hodges responded with Civil Defense Unit 42 to the attacks on the U.S. Capitol as Capitol Police units were overrun. Ofc. Hodges fought those who assaulted the Capitol on the west lawn, the west terrace, and in the tunnel leading out to the inaugural platform, sustaining many injuries in the process. While fighting in the tunnel he was crushed by rioters in the west terrace doors of the Capitol and beaten. He returned to full duty within a month and continues to serve as an officer. Not only does he continue to serve, he also has testified in court cases about January 6 and in a case in the Colorado Supreme Court, which recently ruled  that Donald Trump is disqualified from the state's 2024 ballot under the Constitution's “insurrectionist ban.” Former President Donald Trump formally asked the US Supreme Court to reverse that decision on January 3.

    Along with others who defended democracy on January 6, 2021, Officer Hodges received a Congressional medal, the Presidential Citizens Medal and the Center for Politics’ 2023 Defenders of Democracy award.

    Hodges joined the Washington D.C. Metropolitan Police Department in 2014.  Hodges has also received multiple awards for his services with MPD, including a Commendation medal for responding to a man brandishing a gun and threatening MPD Officers and talking him into disarming and surrendering.  Civil Disturbance Unit 42 is a "rapid response" platoon that is equipped with non-standard defensive gear and is activated for policing a variety of First Amendment assemblies, protests, and riots.

    Links in this episode:

    Officer Daniel Hodges testifies to Congress about the January 6, 2021 attacks on the U.S. Capitol.