Podcast Summary
A horse fountain in Riverside Park sparks an unexpected discovery: An author's background in historical architecture led him to a horse fountain in Riverside Park, uncovering a scandalous story about a Hamilton descendant and a gilded age grifter through extensive research and resources.
Sometimes, uncovering historical mysteries can begin with the most unexpected discoveries. For author Bill Schafer, it all started with a horse fountain in Riverside Park that piqued his interest due to its architectural connection to Grand Central Terminal. This seemingly innocuous find led him down a rabbit hole of research, uncovering a scandalous story about a Hamilton descendant named Ray Hamilton and a gilded age grifter involved in a trial at the dawn of tabloid journalism. The abundance of court records, Ray Hamilton's papers, and newspaper articles provided ample material for a book, ultimately resulting in "The Scandalous Hamiltons." Bill's background in historical architecture not only made the fountain discovery intriguing but also provided a valuable context that deepened his curiosity and ultimately, the success of his research.
Exploring the Impact of Background and Experiences: Backgrounds and experiences shape our lives in significant ways, from celebrating love and appreciation through gifts to finding a taste of home with Airbnb, and navigating through scandalous family histories.
Background and experiences shape our lives in significant ways. The discussion touched upon various topics, from celebrating mothers on Mother's Day with Blue Nile, to finding a taste of home with Airbnb, and the intriguing story of the Hamilton family as presented in the book "The Scandalous Hamiltons." Michelle Norris shared her experiences of traveling and entertaining, emphasizing the value of home and the potential income it could generate through Airbnb. The commercials for Blue Nile and 1800flowers.com highlighted the importance of expressing love and appreciation through gifts. The story of the Hamilton family, as described, showcased how their socially prominent background led to a life of privilege for Ray Hamilton, but his wife Eva's story was vastly different. This 1,000-page court transcripts and hundreds of newspaper articles-worthy scandal took place between 1885 and 1910, involving a West Point grad, a brigadier general, and the great-grandson of Alexander Hamilton. The Hamilton family, much like the Kennedys of their time, were influential New Yorkers, but Ray and Eva's lives diverged greatly. Ray, like most Hamiltons, attended Columbia University and became a real estate developer, while Eva's story was marked by adversity.
A woman's desperate situation leads to deceit and tragedy: Despite limited opportunities, a woman from a disadvantaged background resorted to deceit and ultimately faced tragic consequences when she couldn't provide for her supposed child.
Eva, a woman from a disadvantaged background, found herself in a precarious situation and resorted to prostitution due to limited opportunities. She met Ray in a body house and, despite having no education or positive background, convinced him to marry her by pretending to be pregnant. They had a relationship outside of the body house, with Ray providing for her. However, when Eva wanted to present Ray with a baby as his own, she bought one from a baby farm instead of giving birth. Unfortunately, the baby died due to malnutrition, and Eva failed to consider how to care for the child before its death. This tragic incident underscores the challenges and struggles faced by women in limited circumstances during that time.
Eva's Deceptive Babies: Some people will go to extreme lengths to hide their secrets, even deceiving their loved ones with purchased infants, but ultimately, the truth will surface
Eva Steele, a character in the intriguing story of Robert Ray Hamilton, went to great lengths to deceive her lover, Ray, by giving him multiple babies that she had purchased, disguising her actions through societal norms and the ease of buying infants during that time. Eva's background and perceived lack of intelligence led her to believe she could get away with this elaborate scheme, but it eventually unraveled when a baby nurse noticed inconsistencies and discovered Eva's common-law marriage with a man named Josh Mann. This deception highlights the complexities of human relationships and the lengths some individuals will go to hide their secrets.
The Scandal of Eva and Ray vs. Innovations in Healthcare and Personal Care: While Eva and Ray's scandal dominated headlines, innovations like UnitedHealth Care TriTerm Medical plans and Lume deodorant offered practical solutions to common problems, improving people's lives.
The story of Eva and Ray's tumultuous relationship and the resulting scandal made headlines for years, while the introduction of new products like UnitedHealth Care TriTerm Medical plans and Lume whole body deodorant brought solutions to common problems. Eva's tragic actions led to constant media attention, while advancements in healthcare and personal care continued to improve people's lives. The nurse's revelation of Eva's affair with Josh and the subsequent stabbing incident in Atlantic City on August 26, 1889, made front-page news and stayed there for weeks. The scandal perpetuated for years, with Eva's actions leading to frequent headlines. In contrast, the introduction of UnitedHealth Care TriTerm Medical plans offered flexible, budget-friendly coverage that lasted nearly 3 years, providing peace of mind for many. Meanwhile, Lume whole body deodorant, powered by mandelic acid, offered 72-hour odor control, addressing a common concern for many. With over 300,005 star reviews, Lume's game-changing deodorant provided a solution to an everyday problem without the use of heavy perfumes. As we approach Mother's Day, it's important to remember the caregivers in our lives and take care of ourselves. OneSkin's products, with their proprietary o s one peptide, focus on the cellular aspects of aging, keeping our skin looking and acting younger for longer. With a 15% discount using code SHARON, OneSkin offers an excellent opportunity to prioritize self-care.
The Rise of Tabloid Journalism through the Hamilton Case: The Hamilton case, involving Eva and Ray, brought sensationalism and drama to the courtroom, with tabloids like those owned by Pulitzer capitalizing on the story, leading to the rise of tabloid journalism.
The infamous case of Eva and Ray Hamilton marked the beginning of tabloid journalism in the late 1800s. The public had mixed reactions to Eva, with some seeing her as an evil woman, while others were shocked that a supposedly respectable man like Ray Hamilton was involved. Newspapers, particularly those owned by Joseph Pulitzer, capitalized on the tawdry details of the story, printing sensational headlines and loving the drama Eva brought to the courtroom. One journalist who gained prominence through her coverage of the story was Nellie Bly, who managed to secure an exclusive interview with Eva in prison and published detailed articles about her side of the story. This only added fuel to the fire, keeping the story in the headlines and solidifying the rise of tabloid journalism.
A major news event of the late 1800s: Ray Hamilton's baby sale scandal: The media, through investigative journalism and persistence, uncovered a baby sale scandal in the late 1800s, revealing the truth despite challenges and shaping public discourse.
The media landscape of the late 1800s was not much different from today's in terms of the pursuit of scandals and the role of journalists in uncovering the truth. The story of Ray Hamilton's common law marriage and the baby sale scandal was a major news event of its time, with reporters like Nellie Bly and police officials like Tommy Burns playing crucial roles in bringing the story to light. Despite the challenges of the era, including closed-door depositions and competing narratives, the details of the scandal were eventually made public through the newspapers. The outcome of the scandal was that Beatrice, the baby in question, was taken by Ray's brother and grew up to have a difficult childhood but a fulfilling adult life. The incident serves as a reminder of the enduring role of the media in shaping public discourse and unearthing the truth, even in the face of secrecy and opposition.
Exploring Brands with Distinct Offerings: 1-800-Flowers, eBay, and Quince: 1-800-Flowers specializes in celebrating special occasions with fresh flowers and gifts, eBay ensures authenticity in purchases, and Quince offers luxury fashion at affordable prices with ethical manufacturing
Both 1-800-Flowers and eBay offer high-quality products, with the former focusing on celebrating special occasions with fresh flowers and gifts, and the latter ensuring authenticity in every purchase through their expert verification process. Paige DeSorbo from Giggly Squad introduced Quince, a brand that provides luxury fashion at affordable prices while prioritizing ethical manufacturing. During the creation of her book "I Saw the Fountain," the author had to sift through thousands of historical documents, including court transcripts and newspaper articles. The process involved constant back-and-forth between these sources, as newspaper articles often contained sensationalized details not present in the court documents. Additionally, Ray's personal papers at the historical society contained letters of support from friends and family during the scandal.
Exploring the Intricately Connected Lives of Historical Figures: Through meticulous research and a focus on advancing the story, author Bill Schafer uncovers fascinating details about historical figures and their scandalous lives, including the co-inventor of the electric chair and the ability to buy and return babies in the late 1800s.
Learning from Bill Schafer's discussion about his book "The Scandalous Hamiltons" is the intricately connected web of historical figures and events that came together to create an engaging and captivating story. Schafer shared how he carefully pieced together the narrative, focusing on advancing the story while also incorporating interesting facts about secondary characters. One such character is Dr. Carlos McDonald, who was not only the head of the Alienist department at Bellevue Hospital but also the co-inventor of the electric chair. As Schafer delved deeper into the research, he found himself uncovering fascinating details that he couldn't help but include in the book, despite the challenge of determining what would truly interest readers. The story covers scandalous details, such as a woman being able to buy and even return babies within a matter of weeks in the late 1800s. The book offers a unique perspective on history and the lives of prominent figures, leaving much to be discovered by the reader. Overall, Schafer's dedication to research and storytelling resulted in a rewarding experience, despite initial challenges in getting the book published.
Support the show and help it reach more listeners: Leaving a rating, review, or sharing the episode on social media can increase its visibility and reach, helping us continue producing valuable content
Supporting your favorite podcasts through ratings, reviews, and social media shares can make a significant impact. Our producer, Jenny Snyder, invites you to do so if you enjoyed this episode. These actions help increase the show's visibility and reach, allowing us to continue producing engaging content for you. So, if you found value in today's discussion, kindly leave a rating or review on your preferred podcast platform and share it with your network. Together, we can help spread the word and keep the conversation going. Thank you for your continued support!
